I loved Like a Sister, Kellye Garrett’s prior book, and included it on my list of Mysteries and Thrillers by Black Women Writers. What did I think of this domestic suspense novel? Check out my Review of Missing White Woman by Kellye Garrett!
Missing White Woman by Kellye Garrett
To be published on April 30, 2024 by Mullholland Books. Thanks to the publisher for an advance review copy. I read this book in April 2024.
Jen’s Quick Take on Missing White Woman

- Domestic suspense novel with a very likable…
- …Millennial Main Character (check out my list!)
- Also a female friendship story
- Absorbing case with some good plot twists!
- A Suspense novel by a Black Woman author (check out my full list!)
- Satisfying conclusion that will please mystery fans!
Review of Missing White Woman
The domestic suspense lane is pretty heavily populated with with upper middle class “wine mom” characters, with shady husbands and suspicious neighbors. *sips wine nervously*

I love those books, but I also love a new take.
I’m calling Missing White Woman a domestic suspense novel because the events of the book cause the main character to have a lot of doubt about her new relationship. But her age (unmarried millennial), race (Black), and background (a traumatic experience with the criminal justice system) offered a new perspective on domestic suspense that I really appreciated.
What is Missing White Woman About?
After a life-altering encounter with the criminal justice system in college, Bree has become a guarded person who’s slow to trust others. So a little over ten years later, it’s a BIG step for Bree to agree to leave her home in Baltimore and head off to meet Ty, her new boyfriend, for a romantic weekend at a fancy Airbnb in Jersey City.
Everything seems to be going well, except for the fact that the neighborhood Bree is visiting is all abuzz about Janelle, a (white) missing dog walker. One morning, Bree wakes up to find a dead woman on the main floor of the apartment. Who is she and what is she doing there? Even worse, Ty is missing.
The book’s title is clearly a nod to the fact that missing white women get tons of media coverage, while victims of color get far less. Bree is frantic about where Ty might be, but all everyone wants to talk about is #JusticeforJanelle.
What I Thought of Missing White Woman
I found Bree such a relatable character as she navigates a strange city, a dead body, Ty’s disappearance, plus her own anxiety. She reconnects with an ex-BFF who is now a lawyer. The two of them decide to investigate the case themselves, as Bree is paranoid that the police will once again try to pin something on her.
To me, Missing White Woman was all about Bree and her journey. Investigating the case was a way for Bree to regain what she lost years ago: her control, confidence, and sense of self.
Missing White Woman had some great twists and turns. For you mystery lovers out there who are wary of suspense novels with murky endings, all the loose ends were tied up!
I really enjoyed this and look forward to trying Kellye Garrett’s next book!