Jen Ryland Reviews

Find books you love and get the most out of your reading.

  • Reviews
    • thriller
    • new books
    • mystery
    • adult fiction
    • reeses book club
    • BOTM
    • romance
    • YA
    • Lists
  • Subscribe!
  • Shop!
  • Spoiler Posts
    • Spoiler Posts
  • About
    • Contact Me!
    • Media Kit
    • Giving Back
  • Policies
    • Privacy Policy
    • Giveaway Policy
    • Review Policy
    • Editorial Policy

Review of City Under One Roof

12.26.2022 by Jen Ryland // 4 Comments

City Under One Roof is an interesting hybrid of mystery subgenres. Its setting is pretty unique, too. What did I think of this story of a community locked down in a snowstorm? Check out my review of City Under One Roof by Iris Yamashita.

Review of City Under One Roof

City Under One Roof by Irish Yamashita

Cover of City Under One Roof, which shows a frozen lake with a crack in the ice, with snowy mountains in the background.

To be published on January 10, 2023 by Berkley

Source: ARC from publisher for review

Plot Summary for City Under One Roof

When a local teenager discovers a severed hand and foot washed up on the shore of the small town of Point Mettier, Alaska, Cara Kennedy is on the case. A detective from Anchorage, she has her own motives for investigating the possible murder in this isolated place, which can be accessed only by a tunnel.

After a blizzard causes the tunnel to close indefinitely, Cara is stuck among the odd and suspicious residents of the town—all 205 of whom live in the same high-rise building and are as icy as the weather. Cara teams up with Point Mettier police officer Joe Barkowski, but before long the investigation is upended by fearsome gang members from a nearby native village.

Haunted by her past, Cara soon discovers that everyone in this town has something to hide. Will she be able to unravel their secrets before she unravels?”


What Else Has Iris Yamashita Written?

City Under One Roof is her debut novel. She’s a screenwriter, known for Letters From Iwo Jima, which was nominated for an Academy Award for Best Original Screenplay. Here is Iris Yamashita’s website.


Review of City Under One Roof by Iris Yamashita

I really enjoyed the beginning of City Under One Roof, and I enjoyed the end. The middle, for me, was a bit of a muddle.

But let’s break the book down so you can see if it might be for you.

The book’s beginning was intriguing: the discovery of a severed hand and foot on the shore of a small Alaskan town. True Crime fans like me might suspect that this is based on a very weird real life foot (feet?) mystery that may or may not have been solved. See what you think.

Detective Cara Kennedy shows up to investigate the case. But she has a hidden motivation. Then, a fierce winter storm traps Cara (and all the residents of Point Mettier) in the high rise building where they all live.

I’d thought this was a police procedural, and maybe a locked room mystery.

But then it sort of turned into a cozy mystery in the middle, spending a lot of time on the interactions of some of the town’s very quirky residents. One narrator, Lonnie, has a pet moose and some obvious mental health issues.

It wasn’t a true locked room mystery, either, since there was a group of characters who were able to move freely around.

The town had a bit of a 1990s TV show vibe, like Twin Peaks crossed with Northern Exposure.

I liked Amy Lin, one of the three narrators (along with Cara and Lonnie) a lot. She had a whole dramatic backstory that could have been its own book, and maybe should have.

The middle of the book, for me, got a bit meandering and lost focus. But the end was very suspenseful and things started to come together.

Will You Like City Under One Roof

If you like cozy mysteries, I think you’ll like this. It has a bit more gore than the typical cozy, but not too much. It’s filled with that small town quirk that a lot of cozy mysteries have.

If you like books with a fast pace and a lot of twists, I don’t think this one will be for you. It took me a while to read it and I decided it must be long, but it was 300 pages, so not as long as it felt.

Have you read City Under One Roof? Talk to me in comments!

Categories // Reviews Tags // adult fiction, mystery, new books

About Jen Ryland

Over 12 years of book blogging and reviewing, I have read over 1500 books. A fair and honest reviewer who loves book discussions, I'm here to help you find a book you'll love to read AND give you a place to talk about it and ask questions.
Find me on Instagram and Pinterest as @jenryland!

Subscribe
Login
Notify of

4 Comments
margo
3 years ago

I didnt understand the last paragraph. How did the murdered man end up with a photograph of Cara and her family.

0
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
3 years ago
Reply to  margo

Hi Margo,
I didn’t do a spoiler post on this one and didn’t take notes, but

SPOILERS AHEAD:

didn’t Cara think that the Wolf/Lovansky thing might have had something to do with what happened to Cara’s husband and son? I feel like it was a bit of a cliffhanger and there must be a second book coming.

1
Reply
Tracy
3 years ago

I agree with your points. I liked the beginning, and I love a “city” full of quirky characters (looking at you Three Pines). I also enjoyed the end. The middle felt a little murky, maybe too long? But overall I enjoyed it and I wouldn’t mind going back there in a future book, to find out more about the character’s backstories.

0
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
3 years ago
Reply to  Tracy

Yes! At times it felt like a cozy, with the building full of quirky characters. Then at times it was a police procedural, it was Cara’s grief story and investigation, it was Amy and her mother’s (very interesting) story. I feel like too much got crammed in there and could have been saved for future books, as I think this could have been a series. And the middle definitely got bogged down; I agree.

1
Reply

Recent Posts!

  • Rabbit Rabbit | Slow burn love story
  • Peregrine Hill by Nina de Gramont | Gilded Age Drama
  • The Woods | Plot Summary | Spoilers
  • Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel | Quick Take | Spoilers | Q and A
  • The Party in the Woods | Quick Take and Spoilers 
  • When They Find Me | My Take and Spoilers

Meet Jen!

Since 2011, I have been guiding avid readers toward books they will love and offering a friendly place to discuss them. I publish honest reviews that will help you decide if a book is right for you! Let's talk books! See my full bio!

Contact Me

My contact me page graphic shows a black old fashioned landline with gold trip.

Copyright

Copyright 2016-2026 Jen Ryland LLC, All rights reserved. Duplication of content without permission is strictly prohibited.

Privacy Policy

Find my privacy policy here.

Contact Me

Contact Me!

Copyright © 2026 · Modern Studio Pro On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

wpDiscuz