Did you read The Paper Palace and need to talk about that ending? Need a list of characters or a plot summary? Want to discuss spoilers for The Paper Palace? What do YOU think: does Elle choose Peter or Jonas at the end of The Paper Palace? We have a lot of opinions and thoughts and want to hear yours! Come pull up a chair and join us! Here’s a Spoiler Discussion and Plot Summary for The Paper Palace!
Spoiler Discussion and Plot Summary for The Paper Palace
Here’s a quick list of what’s in the post so you can find what you need:
Brief Synopsis of The Paper Palace
List of Characters in The Paper Palace
What (and where) is The Paper Palace?
List of Events in Elle’s Life in The Paper Palace
Does Elle choose Peter or Jonas at the end of The Paper Palace?
Spoiler Discussion for The Paper Palace
Book Club Questions for the Paper Palace
The Paper Palace by Miranda Cowley Heller was published in 2021 by Riverhead Books.
Very Brief Synopsis of The Paper Palace
If you just want a short synopsis of the story, here you go:
Eleanor (Elle) has spent her summers at her family’s Cape Cod home since childhood. Now fifty-five, she is there with her husband Peter and her three children, plus her mother, Wallace. Elle has also just slept with Jonas, a married childhood friend with whom she’s always had a deep emotional connection.
Elle feels horribly guilty but reflects on her family history, which includes her mother being sexually abused by her stepfather and Elle being raped at age sixteen by her stepbrother, Conrad.
Years ago, after Jonas got Elle to confide in him about the rape, the two of them went out on a boat with Conrad, who was not an experienced sailor. In rough seas, Conrad was knocked overboard and they did not try to save him.
Jonas always had a crush on Elle, but the memory of what what she suffered and of the part the two of them played in Conrad’s death always haunted her.
Elle promised Jonas she’d let him know if she was going to get married, then got engaged without telling him. Jonas subsequently gets married too.
Years later, when Jonas shows up on the Cape, Elle sleeps with him, then spends the rest of the book thinking about her life and her family’s history. All of this leads up to the end and her presumptive choice between Peter and Jonas.
The author thinks her choice is clear, but do we???

Characters in The Paper Palace
Eleanor (Elle) (55, born in 1966). The daughter of Henry and Wallace.
Peter – Elle’s husband, a British journalist.
Jack (17) Maddy (10) and Finn (9) are Elle’s children
Wallace – Elle’s mother
Anna – Elle’s sister. Born two years before Elle, she died of ovarian cancer in her 30s.
Jonas – A painter who is two or three years younger than Elle. They first met when Elle was 10.
Henry – Elle’s father
Dwight and Nancy – the parents of Joanne, Henry’s second wife
Leo – Wallace’s boyfriend after her divorce. A jazz musician with two children.
Conrad – Leo’s son, one year older than Elle. He comes to live with Leo, Wallace, Elle and Anna when Elle is around 12.
Rosemary – Leo’s daughter, three years younger than Elle.
Dixon – a friend of Wallace’s and Anna’s godfather. Married to Andrea.
William and Myrtle – Henry’s parents and Elle’s paternal grandparents
Joanne – Henry’s wife in the 1970s
Mary – Henry’s wife in the 1980s
What is The Paper Palace, anyway?

The Paper Palace is a group of cabins in Cape Cod’s “Back Woods,” which are filled with kettle ponds.
Eleanor’s grandfather Amory was a sculptor who inherited a house (The Big House) on a pond near the small Outer Cape town of Truro.
Amory built four one-bedroom cabins on the pond that he planned to rent out for extra income. He was running low on money so built the cabin interiors out of paperboard. He called the cabins “The Paper Palace.” He left the Big House to his third wife, Pamela, and the Paper Palace to Wallace.
The “paper palace” seems like somewhat of a metaphor for the flimsy family foundation on which Elle’s life is built. Her family has a history of sexual abuse, divorce, and infidelity, all of which have shaped Elle’s life.
Elle’s life in The Paper Palace (Chronological Plot Summary of The Paper Palace)

A lot of The Paper Palace is Elle’s family history, but the narrative jumps back and forth in time.
Here is an approximate list of the major events in Elle’s life:
Elle’s maternal grandparents were Amory (a sculptor) and Nanette (a New York socialite). Nanette divorced Amory when her daughter Wallace (Elle’s mother) and her son Austin (Elle’s uncle) were young.
In the early 1950s, Nanette married Jim, who sexually abused both Wallace and Austin.
After that, Nanette married Vince, a banana salesman. Nanette left him and got a villa in Guatemala in the divorce. Wallace’s brother Austin stayed there, but Wallace went the U.S. to attend boarding school.
Elle’s parents are Wallace and Henry. Wallace had an affair with a neighbor when Elle was four, and Wallace and Henry divorced after that. Henry remarried Joanne when Elle was about seven.
After the divorce, Wallace starts a relationship with Leo, a musician. He has two children, Rosemary and Conrad.
Elle meets a boy named Jonas one summer in Cape Cod in the 1970s, when she is nearly eleven and he is about eight.

About three or four years later, Elle, Leo, Wallace, Elle’s sister Anna, and Conrad are staying at the Paper Palace. Jonas is there as well, and he and Elle spend lots of time together. Anna and Conrad tease Elle about being a cradle robber. Conrad spies on Elle in the bathroom.
That winter, Elle wakes up and realizes Conrad has pulled up her nightgown and masturbated on her. He continues to do this and Elle is too afraid to tell anyone.
The summer Elle is 16 (circa 1982) Elle’s blended family heads to Cape Cod. Conrad watches Elle skinny dip, then rapes her in her cabin. Elle tries to tell her mother something has happened, but then reconsiders and pretends to be sick.
Jonas is also there and they attend sailing camp together. Elle feels like Conrad has ruined the Back Woods for her. Jonas senses something is wrong between Elle and Conrad and Elle finally confides in Jonah that Conrad sexually assaulted her.
Leo plans a family sailing day and Elle convinces Wallace to let Jonas join them. Conrad, Jonas and Elle go out in the sailboat. Conrad isn’t an experienced sailor.

The waves are rough and Conrad is knocked into the water. He is not wearing a life jacket and yells for Conrad and Elle to throw him the life preserver.
They don’t, and Conrad drowns. Elle and Jonas make a blood oath to keep the secret of how Conrad died. Jonas gives Elle a green glass ring.
The next summer, Jonas spends the summer in Maine instead of on the Cape. Leo moves out and Wallace miscarries their baby.
A year later, Wallace finds Elle’s journal, in which she’s written about the rape. Wallace confronts Elle, assuming that Leo raped her. Elle lets her think that.
When Elle is in her 20s, she is almost mugged in London. The mugger wants her to hand over the green ring glass that Jonas gave her. A Brit called Peter rescues her (and her ring) and they start dating.
Elle invites Peter to New York to meet Wallace, who emerges from her deep depression to entertain them.
The next year, Elle runs into Jonas in New York. Four years later, she thinks she sees Jonas at the Whitney Museum. She calls him and then lies to get out of a dinner with Peter’s parents to meet up with him. He makes her promise that if she is ever getting married, she will tell him.
Elle runs into Jonas’s mother in Cape Cod, who congratulates her on her upcoming wedding (apparently reported to her by Wallace.) Jonas’s mom says that he is also getting married, to Gina. Jonas and Elle argue again about her disappearing on him. Elle marries Peter.
A year later, Anna calls, crying. Elle meets her in Cape Cod and Anna says that she has advanced ovarian cancer. Elle tries to tell Anna about what happened on the boat with Conrad, but Anna is distracted. Sadly, Anna dies.

In the present, Elle and her family arrive in Cape Cod. She sees Jonas and Gina fighting. Peter gets called to Memphis for a story and Elle goes with him. Elle visits Conrad’s grave and goes to see Rosemary, who tells her that Conrad raped her too and that she is glad that Conrad is dead.
Elle sleeps with Jonas.
The next day, Peter says he saw Elle kissing Jonas’s hand in the kitchen. Elle reassures him, saying that she and Jonas don’t love each other that way, and that she was kissing Jonas’s hand because he burned it.
Later that night, she and Wallace discuss Leo. Elle tells her mother that it wasn’t Leo who raped her, but Conrad. Wallace tells Elle that there are “some swims you do regret.“
Elle wakes up the next morning and asks Peter to go swimming with her, but he wants to sleep. She can see Jonas waiting across the pond. She takes off her wedding ring “one last time” and heads out for a swim.
What Makes Elle Decide to Cheat With Jonas?
Elle had buried the traumatic part of her past (her rape and the part she and Jonas played in Conrad’s death) and tried to forget about it.
The oath they made to keep the secret about Conrad’s death, and the ring he gave her, were a dark kind of ceremonial promise.
So what made Elle decide to sleep with Jonas after all these years? She had plenty of opportunities. Both of them were in Cape Cod nearly every summer. They know each other’s spouses and families. They both seem to have ties to New York, so they could easily run into each other there, or arrange to meet.
I think it was her trip to Memphis and her conversation with Conrad’s sister Rosemary that finally absolved Elle of any guilt and shame she (wrongfully) felt about Conrad’s assault of her and also over Conrad’s death. I think this conversation finally gave her the freedom to consider being with Jonas.
Spoilers: Does Elle Choose Peter or Jonas at the end of the Paper Palace?
I urge you to read ALL the smart and insightful comments on this post! I can’t thank all of you enough for sharing your thoughts and hope YOU will join the discussion.
If you want a quick recap of some of the possible interpretations of the ending, I have listed them below.
Elle Chooses Jonas at the End of the Paper Palace
The Elle and Jonas are soulmates theory for all you true romantics!
Many commenters feel that, at the end of the Paper Palace, Elle chooses Jonas.
She clearly loves Peter, but feels that her relationship with Jonas is something she never let herself explore because of the trauma of her rape by Conrad and her guilt over the part she and Jonas played in his death.
After talking to Rosemary and realizing that Conrad was a monster, she feels free to finally explore her feelings for Jonas.
Before she goes out to swim, she takes off her wedding ring and squeezes it “one final time,” meaning that she won’t be putting it back on again.
Also, Elle’s mother tells her “two things you never regret, a baby and a swim.” Then she later tells her that “there are some swims you do regret. The problem is, you never know until you take them.”
Some readers interpret the as Wallace suggesting that Elle go explore her connection with Jonas and see where it goes.
Elle Chooses Peter at the End of the Paper Palace
The practical ones among us are on this train. Here is our evidence:
Elle gives Jonas his ring back. I get into the ring symbolism further down, but rings are meaningful in the story.
The fact that she’s taking her wedding ring from Peter off “one last time” could also mean that she will be leaving it on going forward
When she’s confessing all to Wallace about the rape and Conrad, Wallace says “I think you broke his heart when you married Peter.”
An image of young Jonas comes to Elle and she says, “I loved him too.” Past tense. But I must add that (sorry!) she also says (presumably of present-day Jonas) “I do not know him yet.” YET!

When Elle has the opportunity to tell Peter she slept with Jonas, she does not. When Peter says he “knows” about Elle and Jonas, Elle feels pure panic. She’s relieved when all Peter “knows” is that Elle kissed Peter, and even then she convinces him that she was just kissing his burnt hand.
If she were going to leave Peter, this would be the perfect opening for Elle to tell him that. But she doesn’t.
Some people in comments have pointed out the hummingbird clue. Elle sees one at the end of the book and remembers Jonas telling her that hummingbirds are the only birds that can fly backwards (thanks Joana for straightening me out.)
BUT Elle then says “If I could fly backward, I would.” Meaning that she can’t.
Elle then notices that the hummingbird’s wings make an infinity symbol, and she also says that her wedding ring is an “eternal” shape. She decides to do what no other member of her family has done: keep her wedding vows.
Elle Commits Suicide at the End
Okay, this theory is from comments and is more fringe, but I LOVE an out-there theory, IF it is supported in the text. And I think there is some evidence to support it.
There are several drownings in the book: Conrad, the old man in the pond, and Peggy (who nearly drowns but is saved by Wallace.)
There is a point in the story, after Conrad spies on Elle in the bathroom, when Elle contemplates suicide. She thinks about how she would kill herself, picturing tying a rock to her leg and jumping off the boat. She wants Conrad to feel responsible for her death.
On the other hand, she was a teenager at the time and very upset about Conrad spying on her in the bathroom. This could be a thing many children say, an “I’ll be dead and you’ll be sorry” kind of thing.
Elle Sleeps With Jonas One Last Time, and THEN Chooses Peter
Okay, this is my new personal theory at the moment.
When Peter says he “knows” about Jonas, Elle realizes what a terrible mistake she made.
As argued above, the fact that she does NOT admit to sleeping with Jonas is important. It would be the perfect opening to admit it to Peter. It would be so easy for her to agree with Peter that yes, she did it and she’s leaving him. But she doesn’t say that.
When Wallace says, “There are some swims you do regret, Eleanor. The problem is you never know until you take them” she means that she knows that Elle took a “swim” with Jonas.
Maybe that she knows Elle regrets it or thinks she will regret it. And that she understands that Elle had to sleep with Jonas to know that she wanted Peter.
The storm that night is a metaphorical one and after it, Elle’s mind is clear. The hummingbird reminds her that she can’t go backwards and needs to move forward.

Elle takes off her wedding ring “one last time,” meaning that she needs this one last “swim” with Jonas to close the book on them forever.
Themes (and Possible Clues) in the Paper Palace
Ring Symbolism in The Paper Palace

There is a lot of ring symbolism in The Paper Palace.
The green glass ring clearly symbolizes Elle and Jonas’s relationship.
Jonas gives Elle the green glass ring after Conrad dies. They have already made an oath to keep the secret of Conrad’s death and Jonas seems to see this ring as a sort of promise ring.
Peter saves Elle (and the ring) when she’s almost mugged in London.
Later, Elle meets Jonas in a diner New York. She tells Jonas about Peter, then leaves the ring on the table, symbolically ending her relationship with Jonas so she can be with Peter. She tells Jonas that she only wore the ring to remember what they did. Jonas tells her, “Peter isn’t the ring guy. I’m the ring guy.”
In Cape Cod (in the present), Elle finds the green ring in her jewelry box. She tells Jonas that she found it and gives it back to him, another rebuffing of him.
In the final scene of The Paper Palace, Elle takes her wedding ring off “one last time” and leaves it when she goes to meet Jonas in the pond.
Drowning Symbolism in The Paper Palace
I noticed all the water symbolism in the book, but I hadn’t really noticed the drownings until the commenters (who believe Elle committed suicide) pointed it out.
Even if you are skeptical about Elle taking her own life, the water symbolism is important.
Peggy, a girl Elle used to swim with, nearly drowns in a pond while Elle is watching. Wallace drags her out and gives her mouth to mouth.
Book Club Discussion Questions for The Paper Palace
The comments on this post have a LOT of great ideas, but I’ll pull out a few:
Do you think that Elle choose Jonas or Peter and why? Do you agree with her choice? (This could take up the entire book club discussion and a few bottles of wine! The author thinks that Elle’s choice is clear, but if you read the comments there’s more than one opinion.)
How does the book’s inclusion of three generations of Elle’s family history give insight into the choices she makes? If I’d read this book in my twenties, I would have had a much different opinion than I do reading it now.
Discuss the symbolism of rings (see my analysis above here) in the story.
Water is another big motif in the story.
Plus The Paper Palace itself (see my analysis above here) also has a lot of symbolism.
A commenter on this post made a very important point: that talking about fictional characters’ experiences with trauma, sexual assault and sexual abuse can be extremely triggering to those who are survivors. If this is a book club choice, you might want to let members know.
In addition, it was pointed out to me that making a well-intentioned but badly worded comment about a fictional character’s choices or reactions after an assault can be hurtful to survivors of trauma.
I found this article by RAINN (Rape, Abuse and Incest National Network) on speaking with survivors of sexual assault and abuse really helpful and hope you do too.
Spoiler Discussion for The Paper Palace
What are your thoughts about the book? Please leave a comment, and if you want to be notified of responses to your comment (or the entire discussion) PLEASE subscribe to comments. You can turn off the notifications anytime!
If you’re looking for more discussion posts, check out Armchair Book Club! If you are looking for other spoiler discussions, please find my full list here. If you love discussing books, please consider subscribing to my weekly email about new posts AND/OR my monthly mystery and thriller newsletter, where I discuss new books and shows that you need to know about, announce new spoiler discussions, and more! You can sign up here!
If you’re in a book club and looking for new ideas, here’s a book I think would spark a lot of interesting discussion (just like The Paper Palace):

The Christie Affair is the story of two women: novelist Agatha Christie and the fictionalized version of the woman Agatha’s husband is having an affair with. If you’re tired of reading women’s fiction about cheating husbands, me too, but this story has some surprises up its sleeve! If you’ve read it and want to discuss, come over to my Spoiler Discussion for The Christie Affair.

If your book club is open to historical fiction, mystery or romance, then check out my list of books that take place in New York during the Gilded Age.


I think that Elle is going to stay with Peter. She
loves him for his stability and she loves her in-tact family, something she never had. But, I think she’s going to have an ongoing affair with Jonas which would be easy because the
families are friends and they are both in Cape
Cod and New York so meeting up would be easy. In effect, she can have her cake and eat it too.
Mary Kay!!! I can totally see Elle doing that but curious to see what the people who think Elle and Jonas are soulmates are going to make of this idea.
I loved the book, but I had a totally different opinion of the ending. Total confusion as to wether Elle chose Peter or Jones but my take was that she went for a swim to end her life because she could not make a choice. She gave Jonas back the glass ring to end their relationship. She took off her wedding ring for one last time. On one of her swims earlier in the book she talked about what it would be like to drown. I think it was peaceful and not painful. That is why i thought that was how she chose. She could not make the decision to remain with either man. I have read all the comments on the book, and listened to interviews with the author and apparently I am the only one that interpreted the ending this way. Anyone else thought this way.
Chris
Hi Chris! First off I am still laughing that I read that the author thought the ending was clear. We all have so many different opinions. I hadn’t thought of your interpretation, but she does say “take her ring off one last time” and the book did have a prior death by drowning. I personally don’t interpret it that way, but I don’t think it’s that outlandish.
P.S. WHAT did the author say in the interviews???? Who did she choose?
Chris. You weren’t alone. I thought the same thing. There was a lot of foreshadowing throughout the book about suicide, drowning being so quick, going back if you could and being unable to change the choices she made. She made her peace with her mom, she hugged each one of her kids and even said “for one last hug.”
She said she held her ring to her lifeline for the last time. She made the only choice she could which was Peter, but knew she couldn’t live without Jonas so in the end she said goodbye to both her loves and went out for a peaceful swim never to return to anyone. Suicide all the way!
I did not think of that at all, but on my discussion posts, all theories are welcome! I think the points you and Chris make about the water themes and all the “lasts” are really interesting and do make sense, or as much sense as anything else!
I feel this is true. She felt guilt not relief about Rosemary. She blamed herself for not stopping Conrad and allowing him to R. His sister. She said he called Elle’s name. She realized she couldn’t go back and change that (hummingbird). She spoke of her sister waiting for her, the ring to her lifeline and telling everyone goodbye. The guilt of putter her family through everything she went through because of her parents was too much.
I totally felt the same thing. She said goodbye to everyone and left. The drownings as well as the child dying in the dune collapse all seemed like foreshadowing
Trish, I forgot about the dune collapse! I definitely feel that there is support in the text for the suicide theory but I still struggle to figure out why.
It seemed to me that Elle’s meeting with Rosemary made her feel vindicated in her decision not to save Conrad. Maybe she felt she’d wasted all that time feeling guilty? But that doesn’t fit to me either because Jonas clearly wants to be with her. If Jonas had moved on and she felt like she’d lost the love of her life, it would make more sense to me.
I thought the writing was beautiful, and the author wove the present stories and back stories together with great skill. The problem for me was that I felt angry with Elle. I was angry that she never told anyone what Conrad was doing to her. I absolutely do not mean to blame the victim, and I understand Elle was young and had poor role models and supports, but still… If she had told her sister, her mother or Leo, then perhaps they could have dealt with the teenage monster that was Conrad (broken himself). Perhaps they could have saved them all – Elle, Conrad, even Conrad’s sister. And then there would have been no need for Elle to distance herself from Jonas. Instead, Peter saved her, a devoted husband, father, and overall good guy who was willing to move to America to be with his love (even Wallace liked him, haha). Elle walked down that road, and, once she did, I believe she should have stayed for the long haul.
In the end, though, I thought it was clear she chose Jonas. First, she said a sort of goodbye to her children, knowing their lives would never be the same. Then, a part of her conscience still tried to give Peter chances up to the very end – but he wouldn’t look at the storm or take the swim. These refusals essentially affirmed the choice she had already made. So. she said goodbye to her wedding ring (and hence her marriage) and swam to Jonas.
Yes, I struggled with Elle. She was old enough that she could have said something to someone.
(I’m adding this paragraph after reading Deanna’s much appreciated comment below. I am SO sorry if this comment sounded like I was trying to shame or blame anyone. What I was trying to say was that I felt Elle was old enough to have the vocabulary and understanding of her situation to speak out if she wished – not that she was obliged to, or that there is an age at which any survivor should be expected to. And (I think) the commenter to whom I was responding only meant to say that it was sad and unfortunate that the shame and guilt victims are made to feel enables predators to go unpunished. There is no obligation of a survivor of sexual assault or abuse to speak out if they choose not to. But Deanna’s comment is a good reminder for me to choose my words more carefully. If anyone felt judged by my phrasing I am so sorry.)
Given Wallace’s own history of abuse, she should have been less oblivious. The tough part of the book for me was so much history repeating itself, so many broken families leading to more broken people, then repeat and repeat. It made me sad.
Yikes at “she was old enough that she could have said something to someone” and the comment above saying “I understand, but…”, indicating they in fact do not understand? All the women here who are victims of sexual assault who didn’t immediately report or tell family or friends reading this are only getting more reinforcement that they should be ashamed of that too. And many of them may have been older than Elle was when she was abused. There are a lot of complicated feelings of shame and guilt and often times feeling some misguided sense of responsibility that lead to women hiding what happened to them in the first place. You’d be wise to not go around telling the women in your life that you feel this way because if you have, they’re sure to not come to you when they finally do feel comfortable sharing since it seems you’d be less likely to be supportive than to ask, “Why bother saying something now if you didn’t say something then?”
Hi Deanna! First, thank you so much for leaving this comment. It was absolutely not my intention to suggest that there is any correct way for a victim of trauma to behave, but your comment made me realize that aspects of the discussion might be interpreted that way. I am so sorry about that.
Elle had no obligation to tell anyone what happened to her. I feel terrible that the discussion made you (or might make anyone else) feel otherwise. I really appreciate you speaking up about it and again, I sincerely apologize.
I am most definitely on team Peter.He gave Elle what she desperately needed..
a safe,reliable haven in which to grow.What she and Jonas had done would always be part of their relationship and could never be made right.
I welcome all opinions here but I am glad when someone agrees with me!!
Hi Sharlene,
I agree that Elle decided to go to Jonas in the end. In the book she references how Wallace taught her to make a tough decision – chose one path and then you will know what your heart really wants. While Wallace is no role model, this advice rings true to me.
I think Elle makes her decision during the storm and the hummingbird is a turning point. She is the hummingbird in the storm, and she can fly both forward and backwards (back to Jonas). She tries to wake up Peter to show him, but he shows zero interest in something that is truly meaningful to her. She never shared her story with Peter. The life they had is built on a lie. Peter also had the chance to take the swim that morning and he declined. He never truly understood Elle, mainly because she did not let him in.
Right or wrong, going back to Jonas is a sign that Elle is ready to be her true, authentic self. I am team Jonas, but I do think the next chapter of the book would be a lot of painful realities. I have a hard time believing that Elle would allow her children to go through a traumatic break up. However, you age you do reach a point where you realize life is short and you need to make the most of the time you have left.
I’m so glad I found this discussion. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.
Hi Nancy – absolutely love your insights on the hummingbird symbolism. I also love what you said about Elle never letting Peter in. Now she does have the chance to to that, but she chooses not to. And yes on the painful realities. She will have broken up her own family and Jonas’s AND she may realize that the childhood Jonas she had a crush on may not be the person she needs now in her 50s.
Just finished the book so I’m a little late to the conversation but I’m team Peter! I think if anything, the guilt she felt over Conrad should have bonded her to Jonas and kept her from finding happiness with anyone else, but it didn’t. If she really felt so terrible why did she choose a good man like Peter? She could have left Peter when she reconnected with Jonas when she moved back to the city but she didn’t and her and Peter went on to become best friends with Jonas and his wife.
I guess I can’t suspend reality enough to want Elle to leave her family and subject her kids to the dysfunction she grew up with.
Thank you Patty. I love discussing books so much that I have devoted an entire blog to it. I welcome ALL opinions here and it would be boring if we all agreed. But I am happy to find someone who agrees with me, because most people seem to be saying, “Elle, you deserve happiness. Go be with Jonas.”
What happened to Elle when she was sixteen was not fair at all. But she did have nearly 40 years to go to therapy, to talk to her husband about it, and to try to honor the family that she made and the person she became. I am truly sorry that Elle missed her chance to explore a relationship with Jonas but I feel like that ship has sailed. If in the final chapter she had convinced Peter to swim with her and he dropped dead of a heart attack (sorry, Peter) then I might say okay, go for it.
But what about Peter being messy (mentioned over and over), never taking up for her when she needs him to and never taking anything seriously?
I have just finished the book and am completely bewildered with the ending.
I am leaning towards suicide but leaving the wedding ring behind doesn’t fit that scenario.
So I am thinking she chose Jonas which is a shock and as others have said is what her father did and she knew the effect that had on her as a child.
Thinking I might have to re read it …….🤷♀️
Hi Julie and welcome! I have gone back and forth and around and around. I’ve read all the very thoughtful comments here. My initial interpretation is that she left Peter and went to Jonas. But would she do that so disrespectfully? Leave the ring, swim across the pond with her husband and kids right there and be like, “bye guys, it’s been fun but I’m out of here.”
My new take is that she took her ring off to have one last goodbye with Jonas. Probably sleep with him one last time and tell him with regret that she wished things had not happened the way they did but that she can’t go backwards. I think the hummingbird is a reminder of that, and after the rains storm her head is (finally!) clear.
If you do re-read and have another interpretation PLEASE come back and tell us. I love that everyone sees something different in the book. I can’t remember a book I’ve read in which readers come away with such drastically different opinions.
Hi Jen,
As you know from our book conferences together, I, like Lauren, HATE love triangles. Nonetheless I stayed up way too late reading this and have a lot of thoughts. I think the writer makes it clear that Elle can see the safety of staying Peter, whom she does love, but also the joy of finally being free to love Jonas the way she has always wanted. I didn’t really find any of the characters all that lovable but can see how the writer drops so many clues about how Elle’s pretty life with Peter is based on a cracked foundation because she needs him to be her rock and protector. But she no longer needs him to be her safe harbor because she can finally be honest with herself and a partner — just not him. I agree that she desperately wanted him to wake up and join her in both admiring the storm and her morning swim. To me the big revelation is that even when making love to her husband it’s the thought of Jonas that pushes her over the edge. Her life with Jonas might blow up her life, but Jonas isn’t indifferent and unknown to her children like her stepparents were. He loves them, he’s their godfather, and he isn’t going to try to limit Elle’s presence in their lives. I’m a firm believer in fighting for your marriage in real life, but in this story I think Elle felt a deep need to be with Jonas. I disagree with the commenter who said it was always Jonas following her around because it was Elle who called Jonas after seeing the server who reminded her of him at the Whitney and Elle who called him after she had Jack. Jonas is the only other person who truly belongs to the pond like Elle, and for that and myriad other reasons, I think the writer posits that he’s both Elle’s past and her future.
Hi Sandie! So great to hear from you and sorry not to be seeing you at a book conference (though I bet you are going to ALA). You were one of the last book people I saw in person before the pandemic
I find it so interesting that all of us are completely set in our opinions of a) what we think Elle should do and b) what we think she did do in regards to Peter and Jonas. And that we all have evidence and yet many of us disagree. I find your argument 100% compelling and then read another comment and think well… maybe not. (But your last comment about Jonas’s tie to the pond was something I didn’t think of. Maybe another metaphor. Cape Cod has been a place of such joy AND such pain to Elle and maybe now she can find only happiness there.)
Hoping maybe one day we will meet in person and discuss more. Hope you and your family (and dog) are well! I stalk your Instagram to check up on you!
I also find many of the comments here compelling (yours included, natch) — the death by suicide posts are particularly interesting! I feel like I could get on board with a lot of what is said. And I *did* like Peter; that’s what makes the story so painful. None of us would have anything to debate if Peter was a jerk like her step-parents had been! I mean, I HATE adultery full stop. I just *understood* the why of it in this case. I love that you keep up your blog. I accidentally let mine lapse during the pandemic and have been exploring other ways to discuss my reads! Let’s keep in touch!
Hummingbirds are the only birds that CAN fly backwards
Hi Joana – did I write it backwards and no one said anything until now???? Going to check and fix it.