Spoiler Discussion for The Only Survivors

Did you read The Only Survivors by Megan Miranda and need a character list, a plot summary, a discussion of theories and suspects, and a place to talk about the ending of The Only Survivors? Come join my Spoiler Discussion for The Only Survivors

Spoiler Discussion for The Only Survivors

If you need a spoiler-free review or plot summary of the book, you can find that here.

This post will contain:

A Character List for The Only Survivors

Major Events in The Only Survivors

What is the secret the Survivors are keeping?

Who caused the crash, who killed Ben, and did someone kill Clara and Ian?

Spoiler Discussion for The Only Survivors

---

Major characters in The Only Survivors by Megan Miranda

The Survivors (in the present)

Cassidy Bent: works in event planning

Oliver King: works for a hedge fund.

Joshua Doleman: lawyer at Amaya’s family firm

Brody: works as an EMT; new father.

Grace Langly: is a trauma therapist

Amaya Andrews: works at a Tennessee state emergency resource center

Hollis: Brody’s girlfriend back in high school.

Former survivors:

Clara: died on the first anniversary of the crash

Ian Tayler: thought to have drowned shortly before the book starts in May.

Other Characters:

Will: fisherman who lives near the group’s rental house

Russ: Cassidy’s boyfriend

Ben Weaver: survived the crash, but then bled to death.

---

Major Events in The Only Survivors by Megan Miranda

Events of 10 years ago:

The tragedy that the book is centered around happened ten years ago on Habitat for Humanity trip. 

Two vans of high school kids took a detour off the main road. Both vans crashed into the river at Stone River Gorge, Tennessee, reportedly to try to avoid a deer in the road. 

Twelve kids and two teachers (who were driving) died. Some kids were injured or trapped inside the vans.

Nine kids were able to escape from one crashed van and four out of the other.

Almost everyone in the first van survived except the driver.

Grace saw Ben arguing with Mr Kates, driver of the first van. It seems like Ben cheated. Ben suggests that Mr. Kates has an inappropriate relationship with Grace.

After the crash, Grace steals Oliver’s knife and accuses Ben in front of everyone of causing the crash.

The group drew straws for someone to attempt to get to the trapped students. Jason lost the draw, and was swept away by the rising river current. Three other students (Ben, Trinity, and Morgan, died at the scent).

After that, the remaining nine crash survivors decided they would climb out of the river gorge because there was a bad storm and the water was rising. The school had a no cell phone policy so no one could call for help.

---

Major Events in the Only Survivors by Megan Miranda

The Survivors gather every May at an Outer Banks beach house rented by Oliver to commemorate the accident.

This year Cassidy doesn’t want to attend. But someone sends her a news article that reveals that Ian Tayler, one of the survivors, drowned that past March.

Cassidy lies to her boyfriend, Russ, and reluctantly goes to join the other survivors at The Shallows.

Amaya leaves The Shallows.

Cassidy finds Ian’s phone abandoned on the beach, but it’s locked. Will, a neighbor, says that Ian was there in February. 

Trying to solve the mystery of Ian’s death, Cassidy finds a restaurant receipt in a jacket that Ian left in the closet. Then under her bed, Cassidy finds a note from Amaya saying “get out now. “

She learns from Oliver’s rental car receipt that he came a day early without telling them.

They find cameras in the house.

Oliver admits that Ian came to the house in February. Ian asked Oliver to meet him there. But when Oliver arrived Ian had overdosed. Oliver moved the body and stage Ian’s death as a drowning.

Totally creeped out, Cassidy and Grace decide to leave the house and drive back to their hometown.

Cassidy drops Grace at her parents and then goes to Ian’s. His mother says that Grace doesn’t speak to her parents. Also that Ian spiraled after Clara died and “thought he’d be next.”

---

What is the secret that the survivors are keeping?

Someone killed Ben. He was stabbed in the chaos immediately following the accident.

Brody doesn’t seem to know what happened to Ben. Oliver seems to sense Ben’s injury could not have been sustained in a crash. Grace knows Ben was arguing with the teacher lever some indiscretions on both sides. Cassidy knows someone stabbed Ben but doesn’t seem to know who.

---

Who killed Ben, who caused the crash, and who killed Ian?

In a tree at Ian’s house, Cassidy finds the knife that killed Ben.

Cassidy is sure Ian didn’t stab Ben because he was with her, helping Hollis.

When Cassidy arrives back at her own apartment, Josh is there. He got a letter detailing his part in the tragedy and he thinks Cassidy sent it.

Josh decides that Amaya knew her family had covered up the truth. But Cassidy tells him that Ian had the knife and that she found it.

Cassidy reads the letter Josh got and realizes that the information in it was only known to her or Ian. BUT her journals are missing. She’d shown the journals to Ian. He’d told her to get rid of them.

Cassidy is finally able to figure out the password to Ian’s phone, which was written on the restaurant receipt left in his pocket. Ian also has the app that controls the cameras on his phone.

Cassidy gets into the phone and watches the camera footage. The day before Ian died, someone came to see him. Someone who was angry about what his sister Clara told him about the group: they are “bad people.” Clara’s brother says that Clara told him Ian had the knife and someone had written down everything that happened.

It’s Russ. Who is actually Clara’s brother. And has also read Cassidy’s journals.

Cassidy gets a text from Amaya saying she’s going back to the crash site. They all head to Amaya’s house separately: Brody, Grace,Josh, Oliver and Hollis.

Amaya is there, and Russ is also there with a gun.

Who Killed Ian?

Russ insists he didn’t hurt Ian; that he was a mess and overdosed.

Cassidy tells Russ that Ian set up cameras at The Shallows to expose him. She tells him her journals were just a therapy exercise.

Did someone kill Clara?

Russ thinks so. He says that his sister Clara was going to go public with the truth about the accident and Ben’s death, but then she died.

In the comments below, Susan asks a good question: why was Clara excluded from the survivor’s settlement – the money paid out by the school to the victims and the survivors.

Cassidy isn’t clear as to when the money was paid, before or after Clara died, just that it happened “quickly.” So why was Clara excluded?

Then Russ says when he was in town for the library dedication (which happened earlier that year), he asked the lawyers to include Clara in the settlement. Why did he wait so long? Was it after this that he decided to go after Cassidy?

Who killed Ben?

Grace accuses Brody of killing Ben. Brody says he just pushed Ben, and that Clara had the knife.

Cassidy realizes that Grace had to be the one who killed Ben.

Grace says Ben’s death was an accident and the law firm knew all along. She says that Clara had the knife, and that when Ben and Brody were fighting after the accident, she asked Grace to do something.

Cassidy isn’t sure that Ben’s death was an accident.

Grace runs outside with Cassidy and Russ after her.

Cassidy reflects that they all feel responsible: Brody for fighting with Ben; Oliver, for suggesting the plan that led to Jason’s death; Amaya, for convincing them to leave the scene of the accident. And Cassidy too….

There’s a struggle between Grace and Russ. Grace is shot and Russ falls off a cliff.

Who caused the crash?

Cassidy caused the crash. She’d been carsick and gone into the woods to throw up and the van left without her. She ran out into the road to stop them and they crashed. Ian said it was a deer to spare her the guilt of inadvertently causing the crash.

---

After Russ falls, Cassidy rushes to Grace, who says, “don’t tell.”

When the police arrive, the group says Russ had been stalking them. That his grief over Clara’s death made mim angry and obsessed.

Oliver throws the knife that killed Ben off the cliff. The paramedics take Grace away, saying she will be okay.

Did Grace kill Clara to keep the secret of the fact that she killed Ben? And did she push Russ off the cliff?

The group wonders.

---

Spoiler Discussion for The Only Survivors

What did you think of this one? I really enjoyed the narrative structure and the multiple mysteries?

What are the survivors so guilty about? Is someone stalking them? Is it one of them?

I had my eye on Russ (and also fisherman Will) from the get-go. Mostly because it was the same plot twist in a book I read in 2022.

I didn’t figure that Grace was guilty of killing Ben, though I think the book does give a lot of clues and leave a LOT of questions open about this:

Did Grace have a relationship with Mr. Kates and that’s why she killed Ben, to protect Kates and their secret?

Did Grace also kill her best friend Clara, who wanted to go public with their secret?

I could have used another chapter from Grace’s POV, or to have her POV chapter later in the book, to answer some of these questions. These open-ended thrillers are aggravating!

WHAT DID GRACE DO??? Please leave all thoughts and questions in the comments!