Readers Guide for We Are All Guilty Here

While searching Cheyenne’s room, Emmy finds a stash of money, drugs, and birth control pills. Cheyenne’s sister said that Cheyenne had a boyfriend, Jack.

Emmy’s theory: Cheyenne and Madison were groomed by an older man who got them to sell drugs to local teens. They go to Jack Whitlock’s home and he tells them he hates Cheyenne and Madison, who spread rumors he was gay. Also that Cheyenne was dealing drugs at school for a supplier for all the high school kids call “the Perv.”

Gerald tells Emmy that the Highway Patrol found a possibly abduction site and Cheyenne’s necklace. Hannah is furious that Emmy brushed Madison aside because she was upset about a fight with her husband Jonah, a guy Hannah has been telling Emmy is no good for years. 

Emmy’s niece Kaitlynn says that according to school gossip, Cheyenne was sleeping with an older man for money. Gerald calls and says that the large amount of blood at the scene was Cheyenne’s, meaning she is likely dead.

Emmy and her sister in law, high school principal Celia, search Cheyenne’s locker and find racy photos and drugs. Celia also says that she confiscated Cheynne’s burner phone and that Madison snuck into her office and stole the phone’s SIM card.

When the two are in Celia’s office, they see Dale Loudermilk, the chorus teacher, stop in front of Cheyenne’s locker. They follow him to his classroom, where he starts copying files from a secret laptop onto a thumb drive.  He has hundreds of creepy photos of underage girls.

Lionel Faulkner, an FBI agent from Atlanta, questions Dale, who denies the laptop is his. Dale also cleaned his car the morning after the fireworks. His gun is missing and he has no alibi.

Emmy’s Aunt Millie says she saw Madison in her yard, talking to Adam, a guy she hired for landscaping. Adam has an arrest record. Emmy and Gerald go to his house and find a car with scratches on the bumper. Adam’s parents don’t know where he is. 

Adam’s father Walton gives Emmy the keys to their basement. There is also an equipment shed outside. Emmy doesn’t find the girls, but sees a necklace in the yard.

Emmy has a sudden flash of inspiration. Aunt Millie told her that Adam liked to smoke cigarettes and look at her pond.

Emmy finds both girls’ bodies in the pond, weighted down with chains. 

Flash Forward: Twelve Years Later

What has happened in the twelve years?

• Adam Huntsinger is paroled from prison.
• Jack Whitlock made a podcast about Madison and Cheyenne’s case.
• Emmy’s mother Myrna has Alzheimers.
• Jonah and Emmy are divorced
• Emmy’s son Cole has joined the police force. 

And the big news: Adam is out on parole

An exotic dancer identified Adam as the man who sexually assaulted her. The DNA backed up her assertion and gave Adam an alibi for the murders.

Emmy, now Chief Deputy, and her team go over the evidence in Madison and Cheyenne’s case again.

Emmy, her dad and her brother are discussing putting Myrna in a care facility when they get a call about a missing fourteen year-old girl and her bike left behind. 

A reporter named Delva Culpepper is among the angry crowd at Adam’s house. Some are angry Adam was let out, others think he was falsely accused, thanks to Jack’s podcast.

Paul Dalyrimple shows up with a gun and points it at Emmy.

Trying to save her, Gerald is fatally shot. 

In San Francisco Special Agents Jude Archer and Raheem Davidson hold a meeting with victims’ families. This is Archer’s last case before retirement. 

Meanwhile, Emmy is interviewing Elijah Walker, the father of the missing girl, Paisley Walker. He saw a black truck with a bad muffler. Four months ago, he saw Paisley talking to an older guy, a landscaper.

Emmy has been evasive with the police about whether she saw Hannah or Paul shot her father. She doesn’t want Hannah in prison. Dylan is Hannah’s lawyer and also Emmy’s ex. (She and Jonah are divorced.)

Emmy goes to the funeral home. Her father had lung cancer that spread to his liver and was dying.

Jude turns up in North Falls to help with the case and she’s … Martha Clifton? WHAT?

What Happened to Martha?

Martha went off the rails after her brother died. She was drinking, taking drugs, and stealing her Aunt Millie’s car. She left town, and to protect her from the consequences of a car accident she caused, her father told everyone she’d died in an out of town car accident. 

Cole, Emmy and Jude go talk to Carol Walker. They are also trying to run down male and female nudes from Elijah Walker’s phone. Cole tells his mom that the male nude photos on Elijah’s phone are of Jack Whitlock.

How did Cole Know This?

Jack and Cole had a relationship, but Cole learned that Jack using him to get information on his podcast. Woody is still dealing, now out of Jonah’s bar. 

Jude and Cole go talk to Adam. Jude asks him to convince her that he’s not guilty. He says he’s not a pedophile, but Jude reminds him that he raped her when she was fifteen. Henry drowned right after Jude told him about the assault.

Adam says that he never touched Madison and that Cheyenne was promiscuous and selling coke for Woody.

Emmy goes to pick up the case files that Gerald asked Virgil to get out of storage. She talks to Virgil about Jude. He says Jude hit Bubba Rawley with Tommy in the car. After that, Henry and Jude snuck up to the falls to drink and do coke. Henry either went for a swim or fell in the water and drowned. Virgil says Gerald was also a mean drunk, until he went sober. 

Jude, Virgil and Emmy go over the old case files from the Madison/Cheyenne investigation. They learn that Felix Baker gave Cheyenne his old phone which was known as a “pedophile” flip phone as it recorded video. They wonder if Cheyenne was blackmailing her killer. She was meeting him to exchange the mini SD for cash. He chased her in his car and knocked her over and then they went to get Madison.

They all agree that it’s unlikely Adam was organized enough to commit the crime. 

Carl and Jack alibi each other. Woody is the grandson of Bubba Rawley, the man Jude injured by crashing into his car. Dale Loudermilk has no alibi. Could Adam and Dale have been accomplices?

They notice that Dale car put a lot of mileage on the car right before Cheyenne and Madison disappeared. What was that about?

Adam calls the police station, accusing Jude of trying to frame him. He’s barricaded inside his mother’s house. He tells Emmy he had nothing to do with any of it. And someone planted a hammer in his truck. He says Dale was at his house. He suggests he knows who has Paisley.

We Are All Guilty Here: the ending explained

Adam is arrested and Emmy stays to talk to his parents.

She sees Adam’s wallet and remembers seeing the same wallet sticking out of Walton’ Hunsinger’s suitcase the day they were looking for Madison and Cheyenne. Was Walton using Adam’s ID? 

Emmy calls Jude and Cole to tell them her theory: Walton used Adam’s ID to fly to West Virginia and create his alibi. Then he flew back and abducted the girls. When she came to question Adam, Walton said he was wet from the shower, but it was from putting the bodies in the pond.

They also find out that Alma owned an Audi before her eyesight failed, and sold it to Dale’s wife.

Emmy wants to pick up Walton and Alma’s call logs from Virgil’s house. She realizes that Virgil has been doctoring the evidence to hide his connection to Walton. She finds Virgil’s trophies.

WHAT? Walton and Virgil were in it together?

Virgil shows up with a gun. He met Cheyenne at the mall, where he was moonlighting as private security. He learned Cheyenne has been filming them having sex to blackmail him. 

Emmy distracts Virgil, then shoots him.  She checks the barn and finds Paisley, gravely injured but still alive. Virgil does not survive.

Walton confesses: Cheyenne wanted $50,000 for a video of Walton, Virgil, Cheyenne and Madison. Virgil had the plan. Walton wanted to pay them off but Virgil convinced him the girls needed to die.

Hannah won’t be charged since the DA lacks sufficient evidence. Emmy watches the video she filmed of the crowd assembled before her father was shot. As Hannah tried to grab the gun from Paul to save Emmy’s life, she accidentally killed Gerald. 

Jude goes to visit Myrna. Millie is there and Jude asks her how Myrna pulled off her fake pregnancy.

Jude is Emmy’s mother. What????

Jude named her baby Emmy Lou after the country singer. Her parents took in the baby and Jude promised she would not return to town until both of them were dead. Millie was in on it.

Jude suggests she is content to keep pretending to be Emmy’s older sister. She and Emmy have a long conversation about trauma and Emmy reveals that Gerald’s last words were “tell your mother I’m sorry.”

Jude seems hopeful that Emmy will have figured out what Gerald meant, but Emmy gives the message to Myrna.

My Questions and Yours

Do you think I got something wrong (possible; I take notes but I miss things too)?

Do you have questions we can figure out together?

Leave me a comment!

Who is Emmy’s father?

Is it Adam or someone else? I was trying to piece together the timeline:

• Jude says that Adam SA’d her at the bar when she was fifteen.
• Henry drowned right after Jude told him about the assualt
• Martha “died” after year after that.
• Emmy says she was a baby when Martha died

Allen asked: Does Emmy Not Know That Martha/Jude is her mother?

My take is that Emmy realizes that Jude is Martha, but doesn’t know that Martha is her mother.

Emmy continues to call Martha her sister and Myrna her mom even at the end of the book.

In chapter 20, the book’s last chapter, Jude tells Millie that she doesn’t want to blow up Emmy’s life or Cole’s. Millie says “You’re never gonna tell her?” and Jude says “What would be the point?” I assume that Emmy was the result of Adam’s assaulting Jude and maybe Jude didn’t want Emmy to know that or have that burden.

There’s another scene in the last few pages of the book in which Emmy tells Jude that as Gerald was dying he said to Emmy, “Tell your mother I’m sorry.” Jude holds her breath in anticipation, wondering if Emmy figure it out, but Emmy says she passed on the message … to Myrna.

BUT if this is a series, maybe Emmy will figure it out?