Jen Ryland Reviews

Find books you love and get the most out of your reading.

  • Reviews
    • thriller
    • new books
    • mystery
    • adult fiction
    • reeses book club
    • BOTM
    • romance
    • YA
    • Lists
  • Subscribe!
  • Shop!
  • Spoiler Posts
    • Spoiler Posts
  • About
    • Contact Me!
    • Media Kit
    • Giving Back
  • Policies
    • Privacy Policy
    • Giveaway Policy
    • Review Policy
    • Editorial Policy

The Witch by Freida McFadden | Plot Summary | Spoilers

10.07.2026 by Jen Ryland // 10 Comments

My Readers Guide to The Witch by Frieda McFadden has my Quick Take, plus a character list, plot summary, spoilers and a Q and A! Let’s discuss this seemingly paranormal book by Freida McFadden.

Cover of The Witch by Freida McFadden which shows a swing

The Witch by Freida McFadden | Plot Summary | Spoilers

Table of Contents

  • The Witch by Freida McFadden | Plot Summary | Spoilers
    • Jen's Quick Take on The Witch by Freida McFadden
    • Character List for The Witch by Freida McFadden
    • Plot Summary for The Witch by Freida McFadden
    • Spoilers for The Witch and the Ending Explained
    • Questions and Answers

Jen’s Quick Take on The Witch by Freida McFadden

Original photo of The Witch by Freida McFadden on a bookshelf near red books and a J mug
  • The Witch by Freida McFadden seems a little different than her prior books. It has a past/present timeline, with a historical timeline set in the 1690s, and a second narrative in the present.
  • Both timelines feature young women living in Woodhaven, MA.
  • All in all, I don’t consider this one of McFadden’s better books.
  • The suspense level in the present-day narrative is low. I thought the historical narrative was far more interesting, if a bit light on historical details.
  • There were some good reveals. I predicted one (as always, her small number of characters limit the options).
  • My overall take: if you’re a Freida fan and want a mildly spooky story for Halloween, give it a try.
  • Free on Kindle Unlimited
  • Publication date: October 6, 2026. I purchased my own copy.

Character List for The Witch by Freida McFadden

Present Day

  • Julia Barlow: narrator
  • Mick Wheeler:  groundskeeper/housekeeper
  • Leticia /Letty Barlow /Gram: Julia’s grandmother
  • Ethel: Gram’s sister
  • Henry Ziegler: curator of the Woodhaven Museum
  • Celia Caine: Mick’s former fiancee
  • Alastair Dixon: a ghost hunter

1692 Characters

  • Caroline Eldridge
  • Archibald “Archie” Eldridge: Caroline’s older husband
  • Molly Howe: the Eldridge’s maid
  • Hitty Atkins: local herbalist and healer
  • Hiram and Judith: neighbors
  • Dr. John Shaylor
  • Jonas Reeve: suspect as The Night Reaper
  • Deputy Sheriff Oliver Strickland
  • Magistrate Putnam

Plot Summary for The Witch by Freida McFadden

The cover of Freida McFadden's The Witch,which shows a hanging shackle. This is for my Readers Guide to the book which includes a plot summary, character list, and spoilers.

Some chapters in The Witch are VERY short, so at times I have combined two chapters into a single entry.

Prologue 1692

Caroline reveals that every woman in her family died young. But she didn’t expect to be killed for being a witch.

Present Day:

After losing her job, Julia Barlow goes to stay at Pemberton, her grandmother’s house in Massachusetts.

Ethel and Gram tell her she’s staying in Caroline’s old room. Julia’s ancestors, Molly and Archibald, lived in the house, but before that, Archie married Caroline, who was burned at the stake as a witch. Caroline is buried in an unmarked grave in the backyard.

1692:

Caroline lies to her husband Archie and tells him she is finally pregnant. They discuss the fact that three girls have been found strangled in Woodhaven by The Night Reaper. As Caroline feeds a stray cat, Molly, her housemaid chastised her because cats are creatures of the devil. Molly also says she knows that Julia is not really pregnant.

Caroline goes to the town market, where her friend Hitty Atkins gives her a tonic to encourage conception. She also tells Caroline that she’s afraid the Reaper will get her. She buys meat from Elias Fenn, who warns her to stay away from Hitty, who is a witch. Caroline notices a stranger with long flowing hair.

Present:

Julia’s father tells her that the Woodhaven museum wants to buy the house and preserve it as a museum.

Ethel tells Julia to lock her bedroom door at night. Julia remembers that as a child, she heard the voice of a ghostly woman in the house. After that, she had a white patch of hair. That night she hears loud moaning. The next morning, Gram tells her that the moaning was Caroline, who didn’t want her decorative hair combs moved.

1692:

Caroline’s neighbor Hiram comes over to say that his wife Judith is very sick. Hiram asks Caroline to get the doctor, but she decides to talk to Hitty instead. Molly tries to discourage her, saying that Hitty is a witch. At the market, Caroline can’t find Hitty. By the time Caroline returns, Molly already summoned the doctor for Judith.

Present:

Mick tells Julia that the grandfather clock stops every night at 3:41. And his watch does at well. Julia goes to the Woodhaven Museum and meet with the curator, Henry Ziegler, who invites her to dinner to discuss Pemberton. He is about to tell her how Caroline died, but then the chapter ends.

1692:

Figure in a cloak carrying a torch

Dr. Shaylor wants to do a bloodletting, despite Caroline’s objections. But when Judith has some kind of a seizure, the doctor says Judith must be possessed by the devil. He leaves, and Caroline brings Judith’s fever down with compresses.

Caroline walks home through the woods and encounters a cloaked figure. It’s Archie, who tells her the authorities charged Hitty with witchcraft.

Present:

Ethel and Gram tell her that the lights in the house flicker frequently, which Ethel says is Caroline. 

That night Julia hears a woman crying.  She also sees a strange glow coming from the attic, but can’t open the locked door.

1692:

Judith is recovering. Molly asks Caroline if she will attend Hitty’s hanging. Caroline insists that HItty is innocent.

Caroline goes to the jail to advocate for Hitty. She sees the man with long hair being led through the square in shackles. The sheriff tells her he is Jonas Reeve, suspected of being the Night Reaper.

Present:

Julia searches for the key to the attic, and tries to get Gram (who suffers from mild dementia) to loan her copy. Henry arrives to take her to dinner. Henry argues that selling by Pemberton to him, Julia can put Gram in assisted living. They discuss witchcraft accusations and how the girls suffered “fits” that could have been self-induced.

1692:

Caroline learns that Jonas Reeve allegedly murdered a woman named Leonora Row. Archie wants to attend Hitty’s hanging and Caroline reluctantly agrees. Caroline tries to defend Hitty to the crowd. Molly tells Archie that Caroline isn’t really pregnant. Caroline is arrested as a witch and put in jail with Jonas Reeve.

Present:

Henry tells Julia that Caroline was burned, not hanged. Julia insists that Caroline haunts the house, and that there are strange noises and lights in the attic of Pemberton. She wants him to dig up Caroline’s grave, and then downloads a ghost hunter app on her phone. Julia finally gets the attic key from Gram.

Julia goes into the attic. Her ghostbuster app seems useless. She finds a peacock blue dress and two letters from Ethel to her mother that were never mailed. But one is unsealed and Julia reads it. In the letter, Ethel tells her mother that her fiancé died in Vietnam and that she’s pregnant.  The sisters have a maid, Celia, the fiancee of Mick. The next night Julia sees a noose hanging rom a tree and a handprint on the window.

1692:

Reeve tells Caroline she’s going to be hanged. They strip her naked and search her body for a devil’s mark. Jonas is digging into the floor of his cell in an attempt to escape.

Present:

Julia runs into Henry at a local coffee shop. Just then, Alastair Dixon, ghost hunter, shows up. Apparently Julia called him for help.  

Ethel agrees to let Alastair come to the house, which has a huge electromagnetic field. He says they are making Caroline angry, and installs an EVP (Electronic Voice Phenomenon) recorder.

1692:

Deputy Strickland brings Caroline a dress and makes her change in front of him. Jonas tries to defend her but Strickland beats him unconscious. 

Caroline’s trial begins. Before she heads to court, Jonas tells her that Hitty talked to him about Caroline. In court, Caroline sees Molly wearing her peacock blue dress. Witnesses tell outlandish and false stories about Caroline’s alleged witchcraft.  Molly testifies, giving eyewitness accounts of Caroline consorting with the devil. Archie refuses to speak on his wife’s behalf. 

Present:

Julia finds Gram in the yard holding a bone.  Did Caroline tell Gram to dig her body up?

Julia brings the pelvis bone to the museum. Henry is horrified but agrees to send the bone to a friend in Boston for analysis. Julia then moves out of Caroline’s room. She decides to open the second letter that Ethel wrote. Based on the date of this letter and the timing of Ethel’s pregnancy, Ethel must be her biological grandmother. 

Julia realizes there’s a person who should know: Mick. She goes out to the gardening shed to talk to him and sees two small footprints. Mick says he sometimes hears Caroline in the shed. Mick denies knowing anyone named Celia.

1692:

Caroline denies all the accusations. Deputy Strickland offers to show the court the devil’s mark on her arm. He says he will prove to the court that she does not bleed, but pokes her with a dull needle. She’s sentenced to death by hanging.

Present:

Henry calls and says he will have the bone analysis results the next day. He also invites Julia to dinner. Alastair is coming to pick up his EVP recorder, and will have the results analyzed in a week. He thinks there’s something off about the painting of Archie and Molly.

At dinner, Henry offers to help Julia locate Celia. He also thinks Julia should take a DNA test. Henry teaches Julia the foxtrot and she decides she likes him.  When Julia gets home, she steps on one of Caroline’s hair combs, which was on the floor. She then sneaks into Ethel’s room for a hair samples. 

1692:

On the morning of Julia’s execution, Jonas tells her that Hetty said Julia was a witch. As Deputy Strickland comes in with food, Jonas starts having a seizure. When Strickland unlocks his cell, Jonas knocks him unconscious. Jonas tells Caroline that they must burn down the jail and flee so that everyone thinks they died.  They set the jail on fire with Strickland still inside.

Present:

Julia goes over to the museum to talk to Henry. She’s told that Henry worked there in the 1950s but died in a fire, but Henry’s colleagues are pranking her. Henry says the pelvis she found belongs to a man. He also says that Celia Caine had a criminal record for theft before working at Pemberton. When Julia gets home, her room has been searched. 

1692:

Jonas and Caroline flee through the woods. He says he is not a killer, but found Leonora’s body. He suggests Caroline to go her home to try to get some money or jewels.

Present:

Julia can’t find Celia Caine. She asks Gram about her, and Gram becomes very agitated and says that she can’t talk about her. Alastair calls and says there’s something on the tape she needs to hear in person. That night she sees a light in the shed and hears someone outside her bedroom door.  She opens the door to see muddy footprints. 

1692:

Caroline sneaks into the house and starts to break into Archie‘s desk. She hears a woman’s screen. She finds Archie strangling Molly, who is visibly pregnant. Archie is the Night Reaper. (THAT’S why she bumped into him skulking around the woods in a hooded cloak!)

Present:

Alistair Dixon shows up at the door. He plays part of his tape which includes a voice saying “Celia.”  Ethel accuses Julia of calling adult protective services to report Gram, while Julia denies it. Ethel throws Julia out of the house.

Henry calls and confesses to alerting APS. Julia tells him she is leaving Pemberton. On her way out, she decides she has to put the bone back. She sees writing on the wall that says “Julia get out now.” She goes to the backyard with a flashlight, digs a hole, and puts the bone back. When she checks her phone, she sees that Henry left her frantic messages.

Julia calls Henry back. He says Ethel isn’t her grandmother and she isn’t related to Julia at all.  Just as she loses phone service, Ethel appears and says, “I really wish you hadn’t found Ethel.”

Like this post? You can now tell Google to show this site more often in your search results – it only takes one click and will help my content reach you!

Add JenRyland.com as a Google Preferred Source This takes you to Google Search Settings, where you can save this site as a preferred news source so my posts show up more in your Top Stories.

Spoilers for The Witch and the Ending Explained

The woman Julia knew as Ethel is actually Celia. Celia smothered Ethel after she gave birth to Julia’s father, then and told Letty that Ethel died in childbirth. Then she engineered “Ethel’s” falling out with Letty and Ethel’s parents so that they wouldn’t expose her. Pemberton isn’t haunted. Mick shows up and confesses to staging all of the spooky goings on in the house. Celia shoots Mick.

1692:

Caroline is shocked. Archie explains that he killed his first wife, which is why he couldn’t kill Caroline. But he satisfied his killer urges with other women. When Molly turned up pregnant, he knew he had to murder her as well. Archie says he will tell everyone that Caroline killed Molly and when she says that makes no sense he says he’ll kill her. He starts to strangle her.

Present:

Julia is in shock. Celia tells Julia that they have to bury Mick and keeps a gun pointed at her while she digs. Julia tells Celia that Henry knows everything.

Celia’s plan: kill Julia and stage her disappearance. Julia manages to get away and run to the house, but Celia locked the door. Celia is about to shoot Julia when all of a sudden Gram shows up and hits Celia with a shovel.

1692:

A skull and bones lying on the ground

Archie strangles Caroline, but Jonas shoots him. Caroline wants to call the police butt Jonas says no one will believe them. Jonas suggests that maybe everyone will believe that Archie and Molly left town after Caroline’s conviction. They should bury Archie and Molly and then assume their identities in a new town.

Present:

Henry had already called the police, who arrest Celia. Gram says that she saw Celia shoot Mick. She swears that her sister Ethel told her to go outside and get the shovel.

1692:

Jonas buries Archie and Molly’s bodies and then proposes to Caroline.

Epilogue:

Caroline Eldridge finally has a grave next to Archibald and Molly. Henry is convinced that Celia and Mick were the ones who staged the haunting, but Julia wonders if Ethel was whispering to them. Celia was found guilty of murder and sent to prison. They found Ethel’s body and held a funeral for her. Julia’s father got power of attorney over Celia’s estate and the museum purchased Pemberton. When looking for Ethel, they found a man’s skeleton buried with Caroline and are not sure who he was.

1717:

After twenty-five years Jonas and Caroline a.k.a. Archie and Molly do return to Pemberton with a portrait they had painted.

Questions and Answers

Who is really who in The Witch by Freida McFadden? Help!


The people known as Archibald and Molly are actually Jonas and Caroline, who escaped from prison. They went to Caroline’s house to get money for their escape, where Caroline found Archie (The Night Reaper) strangling Molly.

Jonas then shoots Archie, and convinces Caroline that they should leave town pretending to be Molly and Archie. Years, later, they return to Pemberton, still as Archie and Molly.

As for the present day, Julia’s Aunt Ethel is really Celia Caine, Mick’s former fiancee. When Ethel was a single mother giving birth, Celia decided to murder her and take her place. Celia lied to Letty and said that Ethel died in childbirth, then engineered a feud with the sisters’ parents to keep them away. I THINK that Letty adopted Ethel’s son, because Pemberton belongs to her, and then passes to him (Julia’s father)

Yes, this is all a bit thin, but let’s just go with it.

Why did Henry say that Caroline had been burned as a witch?


That’s not technically true. When Caroline and Jonas escaped the jail and set it on fire, I guess it was assumed that Caroline and Jonas died in the fire. So Caroline was convicted of being a witch and then died in a jail fire, which isn’t really the same as what Henry said.

In The Witch, why did Gram agree to let Celia pretend to be Ethel?


Thanks to Pink Amy for reminding me that this was an issue for me. Celia murdered Ethel and then told her sister Letty (Gram) that Ethel died in childbirth, giving birth to Julia’s father. But why would Letty agree to Celia pretending to be Ethel? When did this happen? Why didn’t Letty say anything, and didn’t the fake feud Celia started with Letty and Ethel’s parents make Letty suspicious? It all makes NO sense unless Gram had dementia for decades.

In the Witch, was Pemberton haunted or not?

Mick confesses to most of the haunting, but I think the book still leaves the door open to the fact that someone (Ethel?) is haunting the house. I suppose it could have been Molly too, who was also murdered there.

Help me with the graves in The Witch! Who is buried where again?

Caroline and Jonas bury the real Molly and Archie in a single grave. The book also suggests that Ethel is buried in the backyard. At the end, Julia says that Caroline’s remains were found in the backyard. Where did her remains come from? If Caroline and Jonas fled town right after they burned the jail down, who put Caroline’s remains in the Pemberton backyard?

“Molly” and “Archie” (who are actually Caroline and Jonas) are buried in the family plot. And Julia says that they moved Caroline’s remains there too, but isn’t “Caroline” really Molly? Maybe she’s the one haunting everyone! She’s a husband stealer but she also got murdered and is buried in someone else’s grave!

Categories // Reviews, Spoiler Posts Tags // new books, spoiler discussion, spoilers, suspense

About Jen Ryland

Over 12 years of book blogging and reviewing, I have read over 1500 books. A fair and honest reviewer who loves book discussions, I'm here to help you find a book you'll love to read AND give you a place to talk about it and ask questions.
Find me on Instagram and Pinterest as @jenryland!

Subscribe
Login
Notify of

10 Comments
PINK AMY FELD
1 month ago

I just finished The Witch. It’s probably my favorite Freida McFadden novel because I could root for certain characters. I like having imperfect “good guys.”
I think Julia is mistaken that Caroline’s bone was in the grave, that it was Molly. I do not think Julia was aware of the switcheroo, though I could be mistaken. I too was confused why Caroline was said to have burned at the stake, which is different than a jail fire unless the Putnam wanted to save face and hoped legend would conflate the two.
I did think the whole Celia backstory could have been left out. It added nothing to the present day story.
My favorite part of the book was when the lazy museum worker told Julia that Henry was a ghost.

1
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
1 month ago
Reply to  PINK AMY FELD

I think she should put more humor into her books! I thought Dear Debbie (one of my favorites of hers) was so darkly comic!

Glad you enjoyed it more than I did. I found the present timeline so boring. I have to disagree about Celia because without that the present-day timeline would have had zero plot at all!! What if the present was Julia and Henry investigating Caroline?? That would have tied the two together more. I thought she did a pretty good job with the past narrative, though!

I’m glad she’s trying new things, but I wish she’d just spend a little more time on the books. I think it would make such a difference!

3
Reply
PINK AMY FELD
1 month ago
Reply to  Jen Ryland

Interesting because I didn’t enjoy Dear, Debbie.
I guess with Celia I don’t understand in what world I’d say, “Sure, take over my sister’s life and I’ll raise the baby.”

0
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
1 month ago
Reply to  PINK AMY FELD

That makes sense because she was NOT a character you could root for!

And yes, that is something I meant to add to the Q and A. I feel like FMcF is often weak in character motivation. Celia tells Gram that Ethel died in childbirth, which was plausible. Maybe she suggested the two of them could raise the baby together. But did Celia start pretending to be Ethel after Gram developed dementia? It’s the “I’ll just pretend to be your sister and then engineer a feud with your parents to cover it up, okay?” that didn’t make ANY sense.

2
Reply
Shelby
1 month ago

I just finished the book and from my understanding, the reason Letty was okay with Celia pretending to be Ethel was because Letty was able to assume the role of mother for the baby to raise, as well as avoid exposing her beloved sister for becoming pregnant out of wedlock. I assumed Letty was eager to keep this secrets and act as the baby’s real mom because she was struggling to have her own kids…but maybe my brain filled in this gap haha. Wasn’t Julia’s Dad the only child she ever raised? I can’t remember tbh.

Last edited 1 month ago by Shelby
1
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
1 month ago
Reply to  Shelby

That actually makes a lot of sense. Thanks so much!

And I don’t think we really know anything about Julia’s family besides that she has a dad and a mom named Barbara. Unless I missed something else!

0
Reply
Emmmm
1 month ago
Reply to  Shelby

They also mentioned Letty was having issues having a child. It may have been her only opportunity to have one.

0
Reply
Tash
29 days ago

Most confusing book. My least fav of Freida’s

1
Reply
Barb
13 days ago

I found the book very confusing I’m still not sure who is really buried in the yard and about the painting of Caroline and Jonas. I read the summary and still don’t get it.

0
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
12 days ago
Reply to  Barb

It is very confusing! Everyone thinks the painting is Molly and Archibald, but it’s really Caroline and Jonas, who burned M and A in the fire and took their identities. So the bodies in the family plot are also Caroline and Jonas, and M and A are secretly buried in the backyard. Julia finds Molly’s bones in the yard and, thinking they belong to Caroline, reburies them.

0
Reply

Recent Posts!

  • Rabbit Rabbit | Slow burn love story
  • Peregrine Hill by Nina de Gramont | Gilded Age Drama
  • The Woods | Plot Summary | Spoilers
  • Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel | Quick Take | Spoilers | Q and A
  • The Party in the Woods | Quick Take and Spoilers 
  • When They Find Me | My Take and Spoilers

Meet Jen!

Since 2011, I have been guiding avid readers toward books they will love and offering a friendly place to discuss them. I publish honest reviews that will help you decide if a book is right for you! Let's talk books! See my full bio!

Contact Me

My contact me page graphic shows a black old fashioned landline with gold trip.

Copyright

Copyright 2016-2026 Jen Ryland LLC, All rights reserved. Duplication of content without permission is strictly prohibited.

Privacy Policy

Find my privacy policy here.

Contact Me

Contact Me!

Copyright © 2026 · Modern Studio Pro On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

wpDiscuz