Jen Ryland Reviews

Find books you love and get the most out of your reading.

  • Reviews
    • thriller
    • new books
    • mystery
    • adult fiction
    • reeses book club
    • BOTM
    • romance
    • YA
    • Lists
  • Subscribe!
  • Shop!
  • Spoiler Posts
    • Spoiler Posts
  • About
    • Contact Me!
    • Media Kit
    • Giving Back
  • Policies
    • Privacy Policy
    • Giveaway Policy
    • Review Policy
    • Editorial Policy

Spoiler Discussion for The Guest List

Have you read The Guest List by Lucy Foley? Need a plot summary or the Guest List ending explained? Want to find or discuss Guest List spoilers? Then you’re in the right place! Here is my Spoiler Discussion for the Guest List!

Spoiler Discussion for The Guest List
  • The Guest List by Lucy Foley.
  • Published on June 2, 2020 by William Morrow.
  • Lucy Foley is also the author of The Paris Apartment (2022) and The Midnight Feast (2024)! I’ll link my spoiler posts to those books down below.

Don’t want spoilers? You can find my spoiler-free review of The Guest List here. Then be sure to come back and chat with us, as we have a lot of questions and a lot of thoughts!


Table of Contents for my Spoiler Discussion of the Guest List

  • List of Guest List Characters
  • Guest List Plot Summary
  • List of Suspects
  • Spoiler Discussion for the Guest List

The Who, What and Where of the Guest List

The What: the wedding of power couple Julia Keegan (magazine publisher) and Will Slater (star of a reality show).

The Where: The Folly on Cormorant Island, off the coast of Ireland. Locals say it was site of the massacre of a religious sect. It’s creepy. Some say haunted. Or cursed.

The Guest List takes place on a remote island. Photo of a cliff by the sea

After the wedding is over and the party is underway, the lights go out. Then someone screams. There’s a body outside.

The book’s narrative flashes forward then backward, as the guests reveal and learn secrets about one another. Let’s talk about the guests first.

The Guest List: Groom’s Side

  • Will: The ruggedly handsome groom. He’s the star of a survival show in which he’s blindfolded and dropped in a mysterious location from which he has to escape.
  • Johnno: He’s the best man and has plenty of rough edges. He showed up at the wedding without his bespoke suit. Will’s show was his idea, modeled after a creepy game they and their friends used to play at boarding school. 

The Friends (and Groomsmen)

  • Femi, Duncan, Angus, and Peter 
  • Piers: the producer of Will’s show.
The Guest List - photo of a couple holding hands at their wedding

The Guest List: Bride’s Side

  • Jules: The stunning bride. She’s the manager of a successful design and lifestyle empire. She has a half-sister, Olivia. Her parents divorced and her father remarried. She has only known her fiancee Will for a few months. Just before the wedding, she got an anonymous note that said her husband “isn’t who she thinks” and she shouldn’t marry him. Yikes!
  • Charlie: He’s a longtime friend (and former crush) of the bride. Something dark happened to him at the stag party. He seems to have a history of drinking too much. Being around Jules again (and back with Will’s stag party friends) stresses him out all over again. And it stresses out his wife Hannah!
  • Hannah: She’s Charlie’s wife and a bit jealous of her husband’s long history with the bride. She’s worried about the state of her her marriage to Charlie. She’s still haunted by the suicide of her sister Alice, whose boyfriend uploaded a revenge porn video that led to Alice taking her own life.
  • Olivia : Julia’s younger half-sister. She dropped out of college after her boyfriend broke up with her. She’s here to support Jules, but also seems very fragile and distraught. 

The Guest List: The Staff

Aiofe (pronounced Eeefah) and her partner Freddy – they are the wedding planner and chef.


The Guest List Plot Summary with Spoilers

The Guest List cover on an iPad sitting on a window sill

Immediately after the ceremony, Olivia walks into the ocean and nearly drowns. Afterward, Olivia confides in Hannah that after a breakup she dated an older man and got pregnant.

Johnno finds out that Piers, Will’s producer, wanted both of them to star in Will’s show. But, unbeknownst to Johnno, Will told Piers that Johnno wasn’t interested. Yikes, Will is a backstabber!

Olivia recalls the moment she learned that Will, her sister’s new fiancee, was also her own mystery lover and the father of her baby. Uh-oh, family secrets.

Woman holding her finger in front of her lips

Hannah learns that Charlie cheated on her with Jules.

The ushers blindfold Will (just like in his show) and take him to the Whispering Cave. Johnno stays after and confronts Will about the fact that he blocked Johnno from being in his show.

Johnno recalls how, years ago, he and Will pranked a fellow student during their game. They blindfolded him and tied him up and he drowned as a result. 

Will tells Olivia to keep quiet about their affair – she’s the one who wrote her sister Jules the note warning her about her fiancé.

Hannah learns that Will was the one who uploaded the revenge porn video of her sister. 

Jules overhears Will and Olivia arguing about their relationship. 

After the lights go out, the groomsmen form a search party and finally find that body – it’s Will…

Who were the prime suspects in The Guest List? Many had a motive.

Johnno, who resented Will for depriving him of the chance to be in the show.

Jules, who found out that Will was concealing his affair with her half-sister Olivia.

Olivia, wasn’t the biggest fan of Will and was also distraught about having to keep the secret from Jules.

Hannah, who wanted revenge for her sister’s death.

Who was the killer in the Guest List?

The killer was Aiofe, the wedding planner. She was the sister of Darcey “Loner” Malone, the boy Will and Johnno pranked.

After Loner drowned, he was (supposedly) buried on the island. Johnno, who is always unlucky, gets blamed for Will’s death. He was holding the knife, standing over Will’s body, when the police came. 

Spoiler Discussion for the Guest List:

What did you think of The Guest List?

Here are some of the things we discuss in comments- join the discussion!

The Will/Jules/Olivia Love Triangle

Did Will really not know that he had been involved with both sisters? Olivia used Jules’s apartment as a spot for her trysts with Will. Had Will never been to Jules’s apartment?

Did Johnno deserve what happened to him?

Yes, he and Will carried out the prank that caused Darcey/Loner’s death. So maybe they both got what they deserved. But many of us (including me) felt a little sorry for Johnno.

Where is Darcey/Loner’s body, anyway?

Aiolfe tells Will that there is nothing in the grave, but Johnno claims that Loner’s body was found by the caretaker. What happened to Loner’s body? Who is telling the truth?

What happened to Pete?

He went out with the search party. They notice he’s missing, but he never shows up in the story again. Did he come back? If not, where is he? Check out the comments – Pete was found. He’s alive!


I want to know what YOU thought! Talk to me in comments! If you want to join the discussion, leave a comment. I will reply to every comment, so if you also want to subscribe to the discussion and be notified of my replies and other people’s comments, toggle on the bell next to the comment box and leave an email address.


Spoiler Post for The Paris Apartment by Lucy Foley

Do you love books like the Guest List? I did a whole post on Best Mysteries and Thrillers Set on an Island


Also, here are links to some other Destination Wedding Mysteries and Thrillers:

Her Dark Lies by J. T. Ellison – I have a spoiler post for Her Dark Lies here!


Every Vow You Break by Peter Swanson – my spoiler post on Every Vow You Break is here!


The Guilt Trip by Sandie Jones – you can find my discussion post for The Guilt Trip here.


Dial A for Aunties by Jesse Sutanto – if you need a break from wedding murder, this one was super light and funny!


If you love spoilers, check out my Armchair Book Club – it has all my discussion posts

Subscribe
Login
Notify of

115 Comments
Terri Moore
4 years ago

I really enjoyed the post and am so happy I found it. All of the insights have given me many ideas for a great discussion at book club tonight.

I don’t have answers for all of the plot holes…but I was thinking about one…

What if the author purposefully left out who the couple was that Aoffe caught? Maybe it wasn’t important who they were but the author used it to show that Aoffe had secrets and was good at keeping them. It also showed she had the ability to move about the house/hotel unnoticed and without suspicion.

The other one about Johnno…well, I do believe he goes to jail. We all felt sorry for him because he got so many raw deals involving Will. However, the author wrote him as a sad sack on purpose to subtly foreshadow that, yet again, he’s going to get screwed! Aoeffe got her revenge on Will, an eye for an eye; so, at least Johnno only takes the fall for a murder he didn’t commit.

0
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
4 years ago
Reply to  Terri Moore

Poor Johnno! Hope you have fun at book club, Terri! (Also I like the Aioffe theory!)

0
Reply
Julia
4 years ago

About the couple that Aioffe catches: There is a tophat in the room and only Will and one other (Charlie or Johnno? can’t remember) wears it. Also, each are wearing wedding bands. Aioffe makes a point to say that all married couples are seated together so she can’t work it out either but we know that Hannah and Charlie were seated separately. Surely, Aioffe would have recognized them. I thought it was Hannah & Charlie (hoping they made up) but at the end it sounds like they were barely speaking. So I’m still baffled.

0
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
4 years ago
Reply to  Julia

Wow Julia, that is IMPRESSIVE attention to detail. Would Will, the groom, have time for a hook-up during his own wedding? Maybe Johnno is getting some action? lol this information only adds to the mystery…

0
Reply
Mister
4 years ago
Reply to  Jen Ryland

I loved, loved this book

At Will’s toast I figured out that he was Olivia’s Steven. That lead me to realize that he was Alice’s uni boyfriend who posted the revenge porn. I knew that Will had somehow roped Johnno into killing Loner.
I thought though that Aoife had an older sister – who was the topless girl in the poileroid that Will had. I thought that he threatened her with releasing her pictures, that she drowned herself, and that Aoife was avenging her death.
I totally didn’t see the Aoife as Darcy Malone’s sister. Great twist.

At my realization at Will’s toast, I went back to ch1 and re-listened to the whole book up to that point. There are so many good breadcrumb details.

l enjoyed realizing part way through that our four narrators – which I initially thought were a random guest selection – were all the possible murderer. And the switch to rooting for the murderer.

I like that we got to be inside will’s head at the end. I would have felt unsatisfied if we never heard what his sick perspective was.

I agree with the person who said the couple having sex who Aoife walks in on is just to show how observent she is And loose the guest are.

It’d be nice to hear about Pete, but I don’t mind that we don’t. And his disappearance adds nice suspense.

I wanted Jules to hire Aoife to her magazine sine Aoife clearly can’t continue the wedding business. And I wanted Johnno to take wills roll on survive the night.

I first thought they were going to stage will’s death as a “tragic accident”
In the absence of that, I like the plot of Johnno going down for Will’s death. He says he’s already been in a cell since Loner died. I think Johnno is at peace with going to prison for merder

I thought there was going to be something more sinister about no cell service. That either Jules or Aoife wanted to lure will to an island without cell service.

0
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
4 years ago
Reply to  Mister

Ooh, such great observations. Thanks so much. Makes so much sense now that I think of it that the narrators are the suspects.

0
Reply
Cynthia Goff
4 years ago

I am wondering the same thing.Who was the couple in Will &Jules room&if it wasn’t important why was it part of the story/plot?

1
Reply
Cynthia Goff
4 years ago

I struggled through over half of this book.Thought it was incredibly boring.It only hit interesting toward the latter part.I am one who doesn’t abandon a book once I’ve invested time reading it but I won’t give it more than 3 stars on my review!Sorry!

0
Reply
Cynthia Goff
4 years ago

I don’t want to spend more time on this book,but must have missed the part about Hannah’s sister,Alice.As far as how she died that is.Can anybody enlighten me on this point?Thanks!

0
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
4 years ago
Reply to  Cynthia Goff

No problem – Alice committed suicide after Will (her boyfriend at the time) uploaded a revenge porn video.

0
Reply
Micheline
4 years ago

Ok, just read The Guest List. One comment: Johnno is just as guilty, tide tables, he knew when the tide would come, and he tied the knots. Not at all innocent.

0
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
4 years ago
Reply to  Micheline

Very fair point – but he shouldn’t get all the blame!

0
Reply
Kanika
3 years ago

I have just finished reading this book and I must say I really did NOT expected the wedding planner to be the killer but if I’m being honest since the moment I got to know about the involvement of Will with Olivia and what that did to that poor girl, I wanted him to be the one who was murdered.
Also I feel sooooo bad for Hannah. I mean her whole word turned upside down. First with knowing about Charlie and Jules’s affair and then about Will being responsible for her sister’s suicide.
Although I think Johnno should be punished for his involvement in that poor guy’s death but I do feel bad about him being misunderstood for Will’s murder.
And lastly I feel bad for Olivia and what she had to go through. And I really really want someone to find out about her hurting herself and help her.
Overall it was an amazing read and i really enjoyed it.

0
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
3 years ago
Reply to  Kanika

That is a great point and I agree that Will was a terrible person, which did make for a lot of suspects!

0
Reply
Mellie
3 years ago

So, I am hooked, and now I am rapidly devouring all the Lucy Foley books. I just finished The Guest List. I actually reread it because I thought I missed what happened to Pete, but now I see I didn’t miss it. So, I loved the story and the “6 degrees of separation” twist. I know that it should not bother me that I don’t know what happened to a random and relatively insignificant character, but ….it does!! Why has he gone missing? Was he bog food? Alien abduction? No, seriously, was that the plan, and if so, why? I’m just curious. I am being funneled to The Hunting Party, but I think I will read the Book of Lost of Found next.

0
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
3 years ago
Reply to  Mellie

I told my husband that I think The Guest List is her best book, so I am curious to see what you think. I don’t think I’ve read Book of Lost and Found, just The Hunting Party and The Paris Apartment. It looks like the Book of Lost and Found is more women’s fiction, but I do read that!

0
Reply
Moll
3 years ago
Reply to  Jen Ryland

Im frustrated by the ending, didn’t like it at all. I feel like the abrupt ending ruined the book for me. I didn’t like how Johnny went down for killing Will. I wanted the book ending with everyone knowing how evil Will was, not everyone thinking Johnny did it! And the ending had me looking to see if I missed something or if there was a bonus chapter somewhere…I didn’t feel like there was enough resolution at all. Also, agree with wanting to know what happened to Pete!

0
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
3 years ago
Reply to  Moll

I agree – the trend of ambiguous endings is very frustrating to me too!

0
Reply
Joanna
3 years ago

In terms of the love triangle question: I’m confused as to why this is a point for discussion: the book clearly states that Will and Jules met at that party after Olivia embarrassed herself by drinking too much and was ghosted . So… no, he had never been to her apartment before to have noticed that they were siblings. He also knew who Olivia was when they first met.

0
Reply
ANNA
3 years ago
Reply to  Joanna

He met Olivia as Bella, before he met Jules. Olivia took him to Jule’s apartment where they had sex, because Olivia stayed there for a few weeks whule Jules was out of town. So Will had been to Jules’s apartment with Olivia before he met Jules. So it makes no sense that he was shocked when he saw Olivia at Jules’s family home.

0
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
3 years ago
Reply to  ANNA

Okay! I read the book when it came out which was a while ago!

But inspired by your comment I went back and looked and YES you are right.

Just as you said, Olivia called herself Bella when she met Stephen (aka Will.) lol after Bella Hadid. I’d forgotten that detail.

Bella/Olivia took Stephen/Will to Jules’s flat and they hooked up. He did tell her she was 10 years too young.

Olivia then invited Will to a party at the V & A but got nervous and drank too much, so he put her in a cab and then went inside the museum and met his true soulmate (haha) Jules. Presumably he saw Jules’s apartment at some point before they got engaged.

Olivia says she saw surprise in his eyes when they “met” so Will did NOT make the connection. Either he’s completely brain dead or this is an editing error I guess…

0
Reply
« Previous 1 2 3 4 Next »

Recent Posts!

  • Rabbit Rabbit | Slow burn love story
  • Peregrine Hill by Nina de Gramont | Gilded Age Drama
  • The Woods | Plot Summary | Spoilers
  • Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel | Quick Take | Spoilers | Q and A
  • The Party in the Woods | Quick Take and Spoilers 
  • When They Find Me | My Take and Spoilers

Meet Jen!

Since 2011, I have been guiding avid readers toward books they will love and offering a friendly place to discuss them. I publish honest reviews that will help you decide if a book is right for you! Let's talk books! See my full bio!

Contact Me

My contact me page graphic shows a black old fashioned landline with gold trip.

Copyright

Copyright 2016-2026 Jen Ryland LLC, All rights reserved. Duplication of content without permission is strictly prohibited.

Privacy Policy

Find my privacy policy here.

Contact Me

Contact Me!

Copyright © 2026 · Modern Studio Pro On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

wpDiscuz