Jen Ryland Reviews

Find books you love and get the most out of your reading.

  • Reviews
    • thriller
    • new books
    • mystery
    • adult fiction
    • reeses book club
    • BOTM
    • romance
    • YA
    • Lists
  • Subscribe!
  • Shop!
  • Spoiler Posts
    • Spoiler Posts
  • About
    • Contact Me!
    • Media Kit
    • Giving Back
  • Policies
    • Privacy Policy
    • Giveaway Policy
    • Review Policy
    • Editorial Policy

New Cozy Mystery Books for Winter 2027

12.23.2025 by Jen Ryland // Leave a Comment

What is more cozy than curling up with a mystery in the winter? Here are the New Cozy Mystery Books for Winter 2027: books publishing between January and March 2027. I’ve tagged each one so you can spot your favorite tropes, from amateur detectives to historical cozies to darkly comic stories. Plus, three of my favorites from last winter all have sequels coming out this season!

Shoppers browse in a busy bookstore as snow falls

New Cozy Mystery Books for Winter 2027

Table of Contents

  • New Cozy Mystery Books for Winter 2027
    • Quick Picks: Find Your Winter Cozy Mystery
    • New Cozy Mysteries Coming Out in January 2027
    • New Cozy Winter Mysteries Coming Out in February 2027
    • New Cozy Mysteries Coming Out in March 2027
    • Recommended Cozy Winter Mysteries from 2026

Quick Picks: Find Your Winter Cozy Mystery

If you love…Try this
A bookstore sleuthWhen Harriet Met Homicide by Meg Blakemore
Crossword and puzzle mysteriesMurder Most Cryptic by Alys Cummings
Historical cozies with a literary twistA Fine Residence for Mayhem and Murder by Christy Carlyle
A comic cozy with a hometown sleuthHazel Turner Is in Too Deep by Hannah Karena Jones
A wedding with a body countI’m Not the Only Murderer at This Wedding by Fergus Craig OR Members Only by Emma Rosenblum
A favorite comic series that’s back with book 7!Finlay Donovan Plays With Fire by Elle Cosimano
Cozy romantic suspenseWe Are Never Ever Solving This Murder by Sarah Fox

New Cozy Mysteries Coming Out in January 2027

A couple stands in front of the manhattan skyline.

We Are Never Ever Solving This Murder

We Are Never Ever Solving This Murder (Wyatt Investigations 2) by Sarah Fox: A woman asks the team to investigate her brother’s mysterious death. I read and enjoyed book one, Definitely Maybe Not a Detective. See it below!

  • Amateur sleuths with smoking hot chemistry
  • For fans of Only Murders in the Building

A women peeking over a bookcase

When Harriet Met Homicide

When Harriet Met Homicide by Meg Blakemore: A small-town bookstore owner investigates the mysterious death of her favorite author.

  • Crime-solving booksellers
  • Small town New Hampshire setting

A woman holding a golf club

Members Only

Members Only by Emma Rosenblum: A murder at a society wedding at a country club. By the author of Bad Summer People.

  • Death right before a tony wedding in Greenwich
  • Perfect for fans of The Perfect Couple by Elin Hilderbrand

A woman's feet on a doorstep

Murder Moves In

Murder Moves In by Ellie Alexander: A journalist and her husband discover that their new neighborhood isn’t what it seems.

  • A young couple moves into the “murder house”
  • California coastal setting

red clock tower

A Case of Fear and Favor

A Case of Fear and Favor (Gabriel Ward 3) by Sally Smith: Gabriel investigates a murder at a library.

  • New book in a beloved historical cozy mystery series
  • Set in 1901 London
  • Crime-solving barrister

Lighthouse

A Killing Reputation

A Killing Reputation (Mudflats Murder Club 4) by Brian Thiem: A philanthropist is killed at his own charity gala.

  • Book four in the Mudflats Murder club series
  • Retirement community setting
  • Perfect for fans of The Thursday Murder Club series

Small cottage with the light on

A Fatal Frost

A Fatal Frost (Novel Detectives 5) by Ellie Alexander: An herbalist is stalked, then framed for murder.

  • Bookstore owner/private detective solves mysteries
  • Small town setting
  • Books 1-4 FREE on Kindle Unlimited

New Cozy Winter Mysteries Coming Out in February 2027

Crossword puzzle and coffee

Murder Most Cryptic

Murder Most Cryptic by Alys Cummings: A group of people in an alcoholics’ support group solve the murder of a crossword puzzle setter.

  • Murder club
  • Amateur detective story
  • UK setting

A hand pushing over the groom cake topper on a wedding cake

I’m Not the Only Murderer at This Wedding

I’m Not the Only Murderer at This Wedding (Carol Quinn 2) by Fergus Craig: A murder at the wedding of a Sheldon Oaks resident. I enjoyed book one, I’m Not the Only Murderer in My Retirement Home.

  • Retirement community murder club
  • A paroled killer is part of the club
  • UK Setting
  • Perfect for fans of The Thursday Murder Club Series.

Foxes in suits

Pawsible Suspects

Pawsible Suspects (Sister Jane 18) by Rita Mae Brown: The ever-resourceful Sister Jane Arnold puts her wits and foxhunting savvy to work solving another mystery.

  • Book 18 in a series by a beloved cozy author
  • Talking animal characters, if that is your thing!

Woman sitting at a desk with a dead body on the floor

Please Kill My Boss

Please Kill My Boss by Evie Ross: A woman’s hated boss drops dead in front of her and she decides to hide the body. Since she’s the main suspect, after all. So she and her co-workers need to solve this murder!

  • Female revenge fantasy
  • For fans of Weekend at Bernie’s or Dial A for Aunties

New Cozy Mysteries Coming Out in March 2027

Red brick boarding house

A Fine Residence for Mayhem and Murder

A Fine Residence for Mayhem and Murder by Christy Carlyle: Three women with ties to Frankenstein, Jekyll, and Dorian Gray investigate the death of a fellow boardinghouse resident.

  • Historical cozy set in 1901
  • Literary twist


Woman climbs down a ladder which is on fire

Finlay Donovan Plays With Fire

Finlay Donovan Plays With Fire (Finlay Donovan 7) by Elle Cosimano: Finlay’s nemesis Stacey vanishes right after the two argue.

This is book SEVEN. If you’re behind or forgot what happened in earlier books, I have you covered! Here’s my Series Guide to The Finlay Donovan series.


Woman with sunglasses reading a book

Hazel Turner Is in Too Deep

Hazel Turner Is in Too Deep by Hannah Karena Jones: A woman returns to her hometown, gets back her teenage lifeguard job, and finds two bodies.

  • Comic cozy
  • On my TBR


Woman peeking over a hedge with binoculars

Very Bad Neighbors

Very Bad Neighbors by Sue Hincenbergs: The wife of a hitman learns someone is trying to kill one of their new neighbors.

  • Dark comic fiction
  • For Finlay Donovan fans

Pink mansion, mother and daughter in sunglasses

The Primrose Murder Academy

The Primrose Murder Academy (The Primrose Murder Society 2) by Stacy Hackney: Lila schemes to get her precocious daughter Bea into Stratford Academy, but finds a dead body on the school tour. I read book one, Primrose Murder Society. See it below!

  • Southern setting
  • Mom and daughter living in a nursing home

Woman holding hammer behind her back

The Art of Getting Hammered

The Art of Getting Hammered by Joanna Wallace : A hammer-wielding serial killer gets a job at a pub, where she learns she might have competition. Heads up: this one is dark comedy, as the narrator is a serial killer.

  • Dark comedy

Recommended Cozy Winter Mysteries from 2026

Cover of Definitely Maybe Not a Detective: a new January Suspense Book

Definitely Maybe Not a Detective by Sarah Fox

This NYC set amateur detective story was fun. If you love romantic suspense, this one is for you!

Check out my Goodreads review!


Illustration of a woman knitting and her yarn forms a body outline at the bottom of the blue background

I’m Not The Only Murderer in My Retirement Home by Fergus Craig

Former serial killer Carol has just been released from prison and is hoping for a quiet life at a luxury London retirement home — until a fellow resident is murdered and everyone suspects her.

Check out my review!

Beatrice Ophelia is Flickering Out (Lake Erie 1) by Megan Gerig

A new series! A cozy mystery set in a small Lake Erie town that blends family drama with an amateur sleuth mystery.


Everyone in this Bank is a Thief (Ernest Cunningham 4) by Benjamin Stevenson

Ernest and Juliette head to the bank and are taken hostage by a robber with a strange motive. Apparently, ALL the hostages are thieves of one type or other. I have read the rest of this series, including Someone on This Train is a Murderer and Everyone This Christmas Has a Secret.

My Goodreads review is here!


Finlay Donovan Crosses the Line (Finlay Donovan 6) by Elle Cosimano

I read a sampler of this and it seems promising. FINALLY, poor Vero can be vindicated for stealing the sorority money (iykyk…)

Need a plot refresher: I have a Finlay Donovan series summary post AND a PDF with character lists and FAQs.


Primrose Murder Society by Stacy Hackney

Great for readers who love a mother-daughter detective team. The wife of a disgraced financier has no choice but to move into a retirement community with her precocious tween daughter

My Goodreads review is here!


Stakeouts and Strollers by Rob Phillips

Stay at home dad detective? Balancing sleepless nights and late-night stakeouts? If you want a dad take on the Finlay Donovan books, try this one!

My Goodreads Review is here.


Which of these new cozy mysteries are you most excited about? Let me know in the comments! And for more winter reading, check out my Best Books for Cozy Winter Reading.

Categories // Reviews Tags // Cozy mystery, historical fiction, mystery, new books

About Jen Ryland

Over 12 years of book blogging and reviewing, I have read over 1500 books. A fair and honest reviewer who loves book discussions, I'm here to help you find a book you'll love to read AND give you a place to talk about it and ask questions.
Find me on Instagram and Pinterest as @jenryland!

Subscribe
Login
Notify of

0 Comments

Recent Posts!

  • Rabbit Rabbit | Slow burn love story
  • Peregrine Hill by Nina de Gramont | Gilded Age Drama
  • The Woods | Plot Summary | Spoilers
  • Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel | Quick Take | Spoilers | Q and A
  • The Party in the Woods | Quick Take and Spoilers 
  • When They Find Me | My Take and Spoilers

Meet Jen!

Since 2011, I have been guiding avid readers toward books they will love and offering a friendly place to discuss them. I publish honest reviews that will help you decide if a book is right for you! Let's talk books! See my full bio!

Contact Me

My contact me page graphic shows a black old fashioned landline with gold trip.

Copyright

Copyright 2016-2026 Jen Ryland LLC, All rights reserved. Duplication of content without permission is strictly prohibited.

Privacy Policy

Find my privacy policy here.

Contact Me

Contact Me!

Copyright © 2026 · Modern Studio Pro On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

wpDiscuz