Jen Ryland Reviews

Find books you love and get the most out of your reading.

  • Reviews
    • thriller
    • new books
    • mystery
    • adult fiction
    • reeses book club
    • BOTM
    • romance
    • YA
    • Lists
  • Subscribe!
  • Shop!
  • Spoiler Posts
    • Spoiler Posts
  • About
    • Contact Me!
    • Media Kit
    • Giving Back
  • Policies
    • Privacy Policy
    • Giveaway Policy
    • Review Policy
    • Editorial Policy

The Sequel by Jean Hanff Korelitz: Review With Spoilers

10.01.2024 by Jen Ryland // 6 Comments

The Sequel by Jean Hanff Korelitz is the sequel to the 2021 book The Plot. Confused already? Me too, but I am here to tell you where to get a recap of book one and help you decide whether you will like The Sequel! The Sequel by Jean Hanff Korelitz: Review With Spoilers also contains a Plot Summary and Spoilers for The Sequel.

Graphic for my Review of The Sequel with Plot Summary and Spoilers. The book cover on a pale gray background. The cover is simply a picture of the book with the title on top of another book with the name of the first book

The Sequel by Jean Hanff Korelitz: What You Need to Know

September 2024 was the worst time of my life to read a book like The Sequel. I had food poisoning and then, right after that, a terrible hacking cough. I’m much better, but my brain still is running at about 50% and these books are like Russian Dolls on the page. But I have rallied and stretched myself to the limit. I will rely on your comments so DO NOT HOLD BACK.

An original photo of The Sequel by Jean Hanff Korelitz on a shelf of books with a J mug. The cover has a book called The Sequel stacked on top of a horizontally oriented copy of another book.

The most important thing you need to know about The Sequel:

If you read The Plot, did you HATE the ending? Many of you in the comments of my Spoiler Discussion Post of The Plot told me you did.

If yes, then you will hate The Sequel with the heat of a thousand fiery suns. Just saying. You can read my protected spoilers below and see that I’m right.

Can you read The Sequel without reading The Plot?

Sure, but I would NOT. I think The Plot is a slightly better book and the two books are deeply interconnected.

Should You Read a Plot Summary of the Plot before reading the sequel, The Sequel?

A thousand times yes. The Plot came out in 2021, which was a LONG time ago.

If you read a lot, reading years are like dog years, in which you multiply by seven. So if you read a book a month ago, it seems like seven months. So we all read The Plot decades ago.

Read my Plot Summary of the Plot here!

Review of The Sequel by Jean Hanff Korelitz

The Sequel is a true sequel, picking up right where The Plot left off. This is the non-spoiler part of the review, so I can’t say where that is! (But I will tell you below.)

  • The Sequel was published on October 1, 2024
  • Like The Plot, The Sequel features a story-within-a-story element
  • It’s also a Mystery-Thriller About Writers. If you love this trope as much as I do, check out my list of other titles.
  • I thought The Sequel was much darker, with much more gory content, than The Plot (will explain under spoiler protection below)

Can You tell me ANYTHING about The Sequel?

Yes!

Without spoilers, the book is about Anna, a widow who writes her first novel, Afterword, which is about the lead-up to, and aftermath of, the tragic death of her husband Jake, who was a very successful author.

So in Afterword, Anna rewrites what happens in The Plot but eliminates all the parts about her murdering people. It’s “her truth,” am I right???

Do we get to read Afterword in The Sequel?

No. But we do get to read parts of Evan’s unpublished manuscript. Which, if you remember book one, is HIS version of Anna’s life. We got to read Jake’s version in the excerpts of The Crib (which were in The Plot.) Are you still with me? Leave a comment and ask for help if you need it. It’s a LOT.


So what happens in The Sequel then?

Anna gets anonymous messages (just like Jake!) and realizes that she has NOT tied up all her murder-y loose ends.

Like Yellowface, The Sequel is also a send-up of the publishing industry and writers. In the Acknowledgment to The Plot, the author says that the book “may seem a little hard on writers, but that shouldn’t surprise anyone; we’re hard on ourselves.”

Anna must not really be a writer then, because she looks down on pretty much everyone.

Like Yellowface, both The Plot and The Sequel also have interesting things to say about narratives and how they are constructed, who gets to tell stories and who they “belong” to.

Spoilers for The Sequel by Jean Hanff Korelitz

SPOILERS BELOW! To protect readers who HATE being spoiled you will need to click on the blue “Show Me” box below and log in with a Grow account, Facebook, or Google. By doing so, you will be added to my email list and receive weekly updates about new books! For more information on why I protect my spoilers, please read this post! If you are having any issues check this tutorial OR leave a comment below as I want to help!


What’s Included in these Spoilers Below:

  • 10 second recap of The Plot
  • Anna’s new motive for her crimes in The Plot
  • Is Anna lying about her motive?
  • How Anna’s old (described in The Plot) and new (revealed in The Sequel) crimes fit together

10 second recap: The Sequel opens as (brace yourself) Anna has murdered her husband Jake because:

  • Anna is actually a former teenage mom named Dianna who stole her own daughter Rose’s identity after murdering her
  • Jake (accidentally) wrote the story of Anna’s life and fictionalized it into a bestseller
  • Jake got this idea from a partial manuscript by Anna’s brother Evan, who was himself writing about Anna’s life
  • When Anna found out that her brother did this, she killed him
  • And when Anna found out that Jake stole Evan’s story and published it, she killed him too

The Sequel is entirely from Anna’s point of view

Which (I guess) has to be the case because everyone else involved in her saga (her parents, Rose, Evan, and Jake) has died. Well, ALMOST everyone.

In the book, Anna has just written a novel called The Afterword, which is about a woman named Celeste who falls in love with a struggling writer. Just as he is on the cusp of success, he becomes the target of anonymous attacks. He hides them from his wife, who becomes concerned about his deteriorating state of mind. Sadly, he takes his own life. Sound familiar?

But just as in The Plot, an anonymous troll starts taunting Anna, sending her pages of Evan’s old manuscript with a note that says “sound familiar?” Evan’s manuscript is about a teen mother named Diandra and her daughter Ruby (who are obviously Dianna/Anna and Rose.)

What? Anna thought she’d destroyed every trace of Evan’s manuscript.

Even worse, Anna is being taunted with Evan’s story, the story he stole of Anna/Dianna’s own life. Still with me?

In The Sequel, Anna presents a COMPLETELY new motive for all her crimes:

Anna claims was sexually assaulted at age fifteen, and her parents forced her to go through with the pregnancy and care for the baby. Which, if true, is terrible.

I only say “if true” because to me, this is entirely new information.

During her villain confession at the end of The Plot, Anna mentions nothing about this to Jake. In fact, she suggests she killed her daughter Rose because she was a bitch who never showed her affection for her. (Hello Mommy Dearest!)

I believe victims of sexual assault. But do I believe Anna, a person who murdered her own child?

At first I was unsure, but YES, I do believe Anna/Dianna was assaulted as she described.

I think that serial killers are born AND made. That Anna was born with psychopathic/sociopathic tendencies and that life experiences probably pushed her over the edge.

Here’s the way I see Anna’s crimes:

I’m going to list the crimes in chronological order, even though we don’t find out about them that way.

Phase One: vengeance.

First, Dianna kills the guy who allegedly assaulted and impregnated her. (We learn this in The Sequel). Then, when Rose is a baby, Dianna kills her parents.

Years go by. Dianna learns that her daughter was awarded a college scholarship and is escaping the horror house she grew up in. She is so resentful and jealous that she kills Rose and takes her place in college to get the life she missed out on. (We learn this in The Plot)

Vengeance Phase Body count: 4

Phase Two: Cover-up

You know what they say, the cover-up is always worse than the crime. And they are right. In The Sequel, Anna has to go on a literal killing spree to eliminate everyone who might know what she did. Buckle up!


Evan Parker

He falls into both categories. Anna hated her brother because he was the golden child, but the trigger for killing him was that he had figured out that his niece “Rose” was actually his sister Dianna. And that must mean that Dianna killed her own daughter. (He obviously figured this out because he tells Jake about it in The Plot.)

At this point, Anna is feeling like she got away with things. Finally. But she hears about this popular book about a teen mom who kills her own daughter and takes her place. Okay, but she then learns that the book was written by her brother’s former writing teacher, Jake Bonner.

So “Rose” (formerly Dianna) now morphs into Anna, who engineers a meeting with Jake. And trolls him online, because she’s so angry that he stole her life story. (Actually, you will see if you check my Plot Summary from the Plot, Jake’s version is quite different.)

Jake Bonner

But then Jake starts investigating Evan and his family and the tragic death of “Dianna.” He’s got to go. She poisons his soup. That’s the end of The Plot.

Martin Purcell

He’s a friend of Jake’s from his writing program. In The Sequel, Anna is convinced he must be the person trolling her. He’s not, but he tells Anna he wants to find Evan’s unfinished novel and thinks Evan’s niece Rose must have it. He’s going to find her! Nope. Anna drugs him and pushes him down the stairs. Poor Martin!

Arthur Pickens

Anna’s troll sends a letter to her publisher with an excerpt that describes Rose’s murder. Anna decides it must be Pickens, the lawyer in Georgia she hired to sell their family house after Evan died. She goes to find him, and he kidnaps her and drives her to Rose’s grave site (he wants to her dig up the body so he can test the DNA.) She manages to hit Pickens with the shovel, push him in the hole she was digging, and buries his body.

Betty and Sylvia

This couple bought the Parker home and in a weird turn of events, they are Anna’s trolls AND Betty is also the sister of Patrick, Anna’s first murder victim, AND the aunt of Anna’s daughter Rose.

How did these two women figure out that Dianna/Anna murdered their brother and their niece? Before Anna killed Evan, he sent an entire copy of his manuscript to a literary agent with an SASE. It took the agent a while to read it, reject it, and send it back. Because they’d bought the Parker house, they got the mail. Blame the USPS, or a lack of mail forwarding. Anna shoots them both with Pickens’ gun and stages their deaths as a murder-suicide. Grim!

NUMBER OF PEOPLE ANNA KILLED IN BOTH BOOKS: 10

The Ending Explained of The Sequel by Jean Hanff Korelitz?

I’m sorry to say that Anna gets away with it. (This is what angered SO many of you at the end of The Plot.) Unless there’s a book three…

While I do think Dianna was assaulted as a teenager, she also kills 10 people.

Does this even the score? I guess, but there were plenty of innocent victims who die terrible deaths in The Sequel. Including her own daughter, who did nothing wrong.

Coming Soon: A more thorough reading guide to The Sequel, IF enough people request it. Let me know in the comments!

Categories // Reviews Tags // adult fiction, new books, spoiler discussion, spoilers, suspense

About Jen Ryland

Over 12 years of book blogging and reviewing, I have read over 1500 books. A fair and honest reviewer who loves book discussions, I'm here to help you find a book you'll love to read AND give you a place to talk about it and ask questions.
Find me on Instagram and Pinterest as @jenryland!

Subscribe
Login
Notify of

6 Comments
Laurie
1 year ago

Thank you for this. I was struggling along, about 100 pages in and I’d rather read your reviews then the book. Thanks as always Jen!

0
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
1 year ago
Reply to  Laurie

Aw, thanks so much. I did enjoy this one, but between having to remember the first book and the frustrating (again!) ending, I was left a bit deflated. I do think the books are super-clever though and great for fans of The Kind Worth Killing!

0
Reply
Dr. Diane
1 year ago

I loved this book and you do a wonderful job summarizing and analyzing it. I am discussing it with my book club (in our 40th year!) this week, and with a plot this complicated, it is great to be able to get a quick summary. We all loved The Plot and have been looking forward to this.

0
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
1 year ago
Reply to  Dr. Diane

Wow, that is amazing. I would love to know how you have kept a book club going that long. I am so happy my summary helped!

0
Reply
SBN
8 months ago

Sorry to be picayune here, but the name of Anna’s book is “The Afterword” and not “The Afterward”.

0
Reply
Author
Jen Ryland
8 months ago
Reply to  SBN

Don’t apologize! I was sick when I listened to this and “afterword” and “afterward” sounded the same. But of course, given the literary theme in the titles, Afterword makes so much more sense. Corrected it and much appreciated!

0
Reply

Recent Posts!

  • Readers Guide for The Parisian Heist by Jo Piazza
  • Readers Guide for Hot Girl Murder Club
  • Readers Guide for Getting Away With Murder
  • New Historical Mysteries for July and August 2026
  • Books for Fans of Widow’s Bay
  • Readers Guide for The Whisper Man

Meet Jen!

Since 2011, I have been guiding avid readers toward books they will love and offering a friendly place to discuss them. I publish honest reviews that will help you decide if a book is right for you! Let's talk books! See my full bio!

Contact Me

My contact me page graphic shows a black old fashioned landline with gold trip.

Copyright

Copyright 2016-2026 Jen Ryland LLC, All rights reserved. Duplication of content without permission is strictly prohibited.

Privacy Policy

Find my privacy policy here.

Contact Me

Contact Me!

Copyright © 2026 · Modern Studio Pro On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

wpDiscuz